Can we transform the face of education by looking at global examples? How does the Finnish education system manage to maintain high standards and equality, and can these lessons be applied to the US? What if the secret to improving education lies not in more technology, but in boosting the prestige of the teaching profession? Can we learn from countries like South Korea, Poland, and Finland to reshape the way subjects like math are taught and perceived in the US? Let's explore what can make our education system better.

The Smartest Kids in the World: And How They Got That Way

Andreas Schleicher, a physics student at the University of Hamburg in the mid-1980s, found himself drawn to a lecture on education by a professor named Thomas Postlethwaite. This intrigue led Schleicher to collaborate with Postlethwaite on developing the first international reading test. Despite initial skepticism, Schleicher believed in the potential of data to transform education.

Fast forward to 2000, Schleicher was at the helm of a groundbreaking test called PISA (Program for International Student Assessment). Unlike traditional tests, PISA was designed to assess students' critical thinking and problem-solving abilities. The results were eye-opening. Finland, a country not previously recognized for its educational prowess, emerged as the top performer.

The PISA results caused a stir worldwide, challenging preconceived notions about education. Countries like Germany, widely believed to have one of the best education systems, performed poorly. The United States, despite massive spending on education, only achieved average scores.

Schleicher became a globally recognized figure in education, advising governments on policy and testifying before Congress. Despite criticism, he stood firm in his belief that PISA was the best tool available for measuring critical thinking skills, a vital component of modern education.

The author, intrigued by PISA, decided to take the test herself. Her successful performance confirmed her belief that PISA was indeed different from traditional tests. It also raised concerns about the thinking skills of American students, who were largely underperforming on PISA.

Motivated by her findings, she embarked on a journey to Finland, Korea, and Poland to understand their education systems better. All three countries had shown remarkable improvements in PISA scores and offered different models of success: Finland's trust-based approach, Korea's high-pressure study culture, and Poland's rapid progress despite economic challenges.

Her mission was to see what the rest of the world could learn from these countries and their students, and to understand the real-life implications of PISA's data.

Can Andreas Schleicher's PISA Test Transform Global Education Systems?

Born and raised in Sallisaw, Oklahoma, Kim yearned for more than her small town could offer. With a curious mind and a hunger for knowledge, she felt disconnected from her sports-obsessed peers. Driven by her desire to learn and grow, she devised a plan to raise $10,000 to become an exchange student in Finland, a country known for its world-class education system. 

In her hometown, notable for its depiction in the 1939 book "The Grapes of Wrath," Kim's ambitious goal seemed out of reach. Sallisaw was on the brink of the second-worst depression in U.S. history, and its education system was lackluster at best. Despite these challenges, Kim's determination remained unbroken. She took the SATs in the seventh grade as part of the Duke University Talent Search, scoring higher than 40 percent of college-bound high-school seniors in critical reading. 

Although she initially faced skepticism and amusement from her peers and family, Kim embarked on various fundraising ventures ranging from bake sales to online auctions. Her determination paid off when she won various scholarships and received a crucial donation from her grandparents. 

Kim was accepted into the exchange program and was placed with a host family in Pietarsaari, a small town on Finland's west coast. Despite the stark contrast between her home and destination, Kim's desire to learn and experience a different education system fueled her determination. 

From Oklahoma to Finland: A Small-Town Girl's Pursuit of World-Class Education

Eric, an 18-year-old from Minnetonka, Minnesota, decided to spend a year in Busan, South Korea, living with a host family and attending a local high school. Coming from a high-performing school in one of the top-ranking states for education, Eric was stepping into the world's smartest country.

What awaited Eric in Korea was a stark contrast to his home. Korean students worked tirelessly, spending more than twelve hours at school each weekday. Beyond regular school hours, they attended private tutoring academies known as hagwons. This intense academic culture had secured Korea's place as a global leader in education, but at a considerable cost.

Eric found the Korean education system to be a relentless pressure cooker. While he admired the high expectations for students and their dedication to learning, he also observed the toll it took on them. Many students slept through classes due to exhaustion, and the competition for university placements was fierce and stressful. The intense focus on test scores and rankings created an environment that many students despised.

Despite its harshness, the Korean education system had transformed the country. Once a nation with high poverty and illiteracy rates, South Korea had leveraged education to become an economic powerhouse. However, the pressure to succeed academically often overshadowed the joy of learning.

Eric's experience in Korea taught him a valuable lesson: winning the academic competition could become a goal in itself, potentially losing sight of the purpose of learning. This relentless pursuit of academic excellence could lead to a sense of isolation and a loss of individuality, as he experienced during his year in Busan.

So, what does it truly mean to be number one in education? Is it about the highest test scores or the most rigorous academic programs? Or is it about fostering a love for learning and encouraging individuality? As Eric's experience in Korea shows, the answer might not be as straightforward as it seems.

Can the World's Smartest Country Foster a Love for Learning Over High Test Scores?

Meet Tom, an American exchange student in Poland. On his first day of school, he's asked to solve a polynomial problem at the chalkboard in front of his classmates. Despite his cool exterior, under the surface, Tom battles with a common American burden - a struggle with math.

Growing up in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, Tom always felt that his hometown, though steeped in history, lacked the cultural richness he craved. He was drawn to the arts, playing the cello and immersing himself in Woody Allen movies and World War II history. His parents, both involved in the law, coped with the stress of their jobs by reading - a passion they passed onto Tom. 

However, despite his love for literature and the arts, math was always a weak point for Tom. Like many American students, he felt lost and humiliated by his struggle with math, a subject that seemed to elude him.

Interestingly, math is seen as a universal language of logic. It's a discipline that requires rigorous thinking and has a significant impact on a student's future success. American teenagers, including the most privileged, score poorly in math compared to their global peers. Even in states like Minnesota, which has a relatively strong education system, students still struggle with math. Despite some improvements, the problem persists. 

Throughout his time in Poland, Tom notices differences in how math is taught. Unlike in the U.S where calculators are a staple, Polish students solve problems mentally, using tricks that have become second nature to them. They also seem to handle failure better, viewing it as a normal part of learning rather than a devastating blow. 

In comparison, Tom's classmate Eric from Minnesota finds math in Korea interesting because it transcends the boundaries of disciplines, weaving together geometry, trigonometry, and calculus. This fluid approach to math teaching is something even Minnesota hasn't quite mastered yet. 

The struggle with math seems to be an American phenomenon. In the U.S, math is often seen as an innate ability rather than a skill that can be improved with practice. There's a need to change this mindset and recognize the importance of math in modern life. Like learning a foreign language, children can, and should, be introduced to the language of math early on. Otherwise, the struggle with math will continue to be an American burden. 

Overcoming the American Burden: A New Perspective on Math Education from Poland and Korea

Kim, the exchange student from Oklahoma, found herself navigating the stark contrasts of the Finnish education system in Pietarsaari - a small town on the west coast of Finland. She was surprised by the dark, icy mornings, the seemingly dreary school buildings, the simple Finnish she struggled with, and the distinct lack of high-tech teaching tools. 

Yet, Kim also noticed an unexpected seriousness about education. Even the "stoner kid" was attentive and studious, and the teachers, like her Finnish teacher Tiina Stara, seemed more dedicated and resourceful.

In sharp contrast, Kim reflected on her Oklahoma high school, where most teachers, including her math teacher Scott Bethel, were sports coaches and teaching was a secondary career choice. They lacked rigorous training, their classes were easy, and often their students didn’t take education seriously.

Kim's journey reveals the essence of Finland's education system - highly selective teacher training universities, intensive training programs, and a culture of trust in teachers' abilities. This contrasts sharply with the US system, where teacher training is often low-standard and the profession lacks prestige. 

This underlines the importance of raising standards in teacher education and making the profession more selective, following Finland’s example. It suggests that a shift in approach, from focusing on complex evaluations and data analysis to investing in teacher education and training, could lead to a revolution in the education system. 

Could Finland's High-Prestige Teaching Profession be the Secret to Revolutionizing Education Worldwide?

Remember Eric, the young American exchange student in Busan, South Korea, and meet Jenny, a Korean girl with an American accent. Striking up a conversation on a crowded bus, the two share stories of their contrasting experiences in the American and Korean education systems. 

Jenny, who spent her early years in Nebraska and Pittsburgh, now ranks twenty-seventh in her sophomore class of around four hundred students in Korea, a position she’s not satisfied with. Eric, on the other hand, is perplexed by the high-pressure, study-centric Korean education system, which seems to be a world apart from his experiences back in Minnesota.

Let's explore two distinct education systems through Eric and Jenny's perspectives, and discover the cultural and societal factors that influence students' attitudes towards learning. It's not just about academic prowess, but also about drive, resilience, and character. 

In Finland and Korea, education is seen as a national treasure, and students are driven to excel. They're not just running on a hamster wheel; they're on a mission to master complex academic material. This 'drive' is a shared ethos that permeates their societies. 

However, in the US, the emphasis on sports and non-academic activities often dilutes the focus on academics. Coupled with less rigorous material, this creates a less academically driven culture. 

So, why are some countries more academically driven than others? It comes down to the value they place on education. The 'drive' to learn is a collective mind-set, cultivated not just by the education system, but also by societal values and expectations. 

Finland and Korea, despite their contrasting methods, have achieved a consensus around rigor in education. The challenge for countries like the US is how to foster a similar ethos. Is it possible to instill this 'drive' in places where it's currently lacking? 

But one thing is clear: the importance of education is not just about learning but also about nurturing character. And character, as research shows, is more malleable than IQ. It's not just about finding the smart kids, but also about finding the ones who get the job done, whatever the job may be. 

Education Systems Uncovered: A Tale of Minnesota, Busan, and the Global Quest for Academic Drive

Despite a history steeped in World War II turmoil, Wroclaw, a city in Poland, has experienced a remarkable transformation in its education system. 

Tom, a child from the city, is a living testament to this educational metamorphosis. His high school, located in a notoriously crime-ridden neighborhood known as the Bermuda Triangle, is a beacon of hope in an otherwise grim setting. The school is a product of sweeping reforms introduced in 1997 by Miroslaw Handke, Poland’s minister of education at the time. 

Handke’s reforms aimed to inject rigor into the system, introduce regular standardized testing, delay student tracking until age 16, and grant schools more autonomy.

The reforms were met with resistance and skepticism. Many doubted their efficacy and feared the changes were too radical. 

However, the results spoke for themselves. In just a few years, Poland managed to catch up with the developed world in terms of educational outcomes. This improvement was particularly noticeable among students who would have otherwise been sent to vocational schools at age 15. The delay in tracking resulted in these students performing significantly better than their counterparts just a few years prior.

Yet, challenges remained. Despite the improvements, many Poles were still dissatisfied with their education system. Teachers were underpaid and overworked, and the quality of teacher training varied dramatically. Despite these problems, Poland's education reforms had proven that even in difficult circumstances, it was possible to raise educational standards and outcomes.

Can Education Reform Turn a War-Torn City into a Beacon of Hope?

Remember Kim, the exchange student in Finland. She found herself in a deep depression during the harsh Finnish winter. Sent to Helsinki to see a psychologist, she began to explore the city and its people, finding herself drawn to the autonomous, independent children she saw navigating the city. After being cleared to stay in Finland, she was placed with a new host family and resolved to be more assertive about her needs. 

She learnt about the Finnish concept of 'sisu,' a kind of inner strength and resilience in the face of adversity, which she embraced. Upon returning to the US, she decided not to return to her old high school and instead applied to a virtual high school, wanting to maintain her newfound independence. 

Kim's Finnish teacher worried about the pressure exerted on students by regular testing, but acknowledged the importance of such testing in maintaining high educational standards. She contrasted this rigorous approach with the less demanding testing system in the US.

In Finland, Kim observed that most students are white, and the country as a whole was not very diverse. However, she also saw that the education system doesn't let poverty dictate a child's educational journey. The Finnish belief is that all kids can improve, irrespective of their background.

Kim's experience in Finland makes her question the narrative in the US that blames educational mediocrity on kids' backgrounds and neighborhoods. She sees how the Finnish approach, which treats all kids as equal and capable of improvement, could benefit the US system.

Finally, Kim delves into the concept of school choice and competition, seeing how parental anxieties can affect a school's reputation. She wonders what would happen in a true free market for education, where schools would be judged on their rigor and teacher quality, rather than the ethnicity or income level of their students. 

Redefining Education: A Comparative Study of US, Finnish and South Korean Systems

Imagine a teacher who earns $4 million a year. Sounds fictitious, right? Not in South Korea. Meet Andrew Kim, an English teacher at Megastudy, a private afterschool tutoring program in Seoul. He's a rock star in the world of education, earning his fortune by teaching in an environment where demand for his skills is sky-high.

Kim's teaching style is far from traditional. He only teaches three in-person lectures per week and spends the rest of his time responding to students’ online queries, developing lesson plans, and writing textbooks. His lectures are available online, and students pay $3.50 per hour to access them. This innovative approach has garnered him a following of 150,000 students who annually watch his online lectures.

What if we could adopt this model globally? What if the best teachers were millionaires? Could this be the key to attracting top talent into the teaching profession and boosting educational outcomes?

However, the story is not all rosy. The private tutoring industry in Korea, known as hagwons, is a billion-dollar business, and it's highly competitive. Hagwons are often accused of contributing to educational inequality and placing excessive pressure on students. 

In contrast, Finland is seen as an ideal educational model. It has a radically logical hiring approach for teachers, tracking their performance and letting underperforming teachers go. Finnish students also enjoy a more balanced life compared to their Korean counterparts.

Back in the United States, there are stark variations in the quality of education students receive. This is largely due to the lack of consensus around the importance of academic rigor. Some educators, like William Taylor, a math teacher in Washington, D.C., are attempting to change this narrative by implementing more rigorous learning standards in their classrooms. 

So, how do we bridge these educational gaps? How do we ensure that all children, regardless of their socioeconomic status, have access to quality education? Perhaps the answer lies in adopting a blend of the rigor seen in Korean hagwons and the balance found in Finnish schools, while also championing the efforts of educators like Taylor.

Could Millionaire Teachers Be the Future of Global Education?

In the mid-80s, Andreas Schleicher developed the first international reading test, believing in the transformative potential of data in education. He later spearheaded PISA, a test designed to assess critical thinking and problem-solving skills, which revealed surprising results about global education systems. His work emphasized the importance of these skills in modern education.

Countries like Finland, Korea, and Poland, despite their different educational approaches, have shown significant improvements in PISA scores. Finland's system is based on trust, Korea's is a high-pressure study culture, and Poland made rapid progress despite economic challenges. These countries can offer valuable insights for improving education worldwide.

There is a need to address the issue of math education in the U.S. as it is often seen as an innate ability rather than a skill that can be developed with practice. This mindset needs to change, and children should be introduced to math early on, just like a foreign language.

Teacher education and training are crucial to improving education systems, as seen in Finland. The profession in the U.S. needs to be more selective with higher training standards, and investment should be made in this area instead of focusing solely on complex evaluations and data analysis.

The drive to learn and excel in academics varies across countries and cultures. Countries that place a high value on education, such as Finland and Korea, have managed to cultivate a collective mindset of academic rigour. This drive is not just about academics, but also about developing character. The challenge for countries like the U.S. is to foster a similar ethos.

Poland's radical education reforms, such as introducing regular standardized testing, delaying student tracking, and granting schools more autonomy, led to significant improvements in educational outcomes despite initial resistance and skepticism. This suggests that raising educational standards is possible even under difficult circumstances.

The narrative that blames educational mediocrity on kids' backgrounds and neighborhoods needs to be questioned. The Finnish approach of treating all kids as equal and capable of improvement could benefit the U.S. system. Moreover, schools should be judged on their rigor and teacher quality, rather than the ethnicity or income level of their students.

The success of private tutoring in Korea, despite its drawbacks, raises the question of whether similar models could be applied globally to attract top talent into the teaching profession and boost educational outcomes. However, to ensure that all children have access to quality education, it may be necessary to adopt a blend of the rigor seen in Korean tutoring systems and the balance found in Finnish schools.


Home

Trending

Collections

Key Ideas & Notes

Insights

Highlights & Bookmarks

Listening History