Are you ready to redefine success on your own terms? Do you want to trade traditional work ethics and societal norms for a life that brings you pure joy and fulfillment? What if you could follow the pathless path, prioritizing health, relationships, creativity, and fun over career achievements? Dive into this transformative journey of a former McKinsey consultant as he grapples with personal crises, embraces change, and dares to explore a life beyond conventional definitions of success.

The Pathless Path: Imagining a New Story For Work and Life

William Deresiewicz coined the term “hoop-jumper” to describe Yale students more focused on grades and resumes than genuine curiosity. A similar tale unfolded in Paul Millerd's journey. 

Growing up with a hands-off approach from his parents, his sole ambition was attending the University of Connecticut for its basketball games. Once admitted into the honors program, he was surrounded by high achievers with five-year plans and perfect SAT scores. Their success ethic rubbed off on him, and he soon became obsessed with optimizing his schedule to secure easy A’s and impressive achievements.

By his senior year, Paul aimed to break into the elite world of strategy consulting. Despite not attending a target school, he was determined to join prestigious firms like McKinsey. After numerous rejections, he settled for General Electric’s Financial Management Program, a prestigious role in his school’s context. However, his unease grew, and he moved to Boston, reigniting his job search and eventually landing a position at McKinsey.

At McKinsey, surrounded by ambitious peers, Paul adopted a career-centric mindset, constantly planning his next move. However, a health crisis changed everything. Diagnosed with Lyme disease, he faced persistent fatigue and pain. Writing became his outlet, and he started a blog to share his journey. Support from friends and colleagues helped him navigate this challenging period, and he began to question his life’s purpose.

Losing his grandfather further deepened Paul's introspection, highlighting the importance of family and relationships. Returning to business school, he focused more on creating memories than chasing grades. However, old habits die hard, and he found himself applying to consulting firms again, facing rejections, and eventually joining a small firm in Boston.

Exposure to the gig economy intrigued him, but his health issues dominated his time. After numerous treatments and a year-long struggle, Paul started to improve and return to work. This experience reshaped his identity, shifting his focus from achievements to appreciating life’s simpler joys.

Professors Richard Tedeschi and Lawrence Calhoun suggest that crises often lead to “post-traumatic growth,” manifesting as a deeper appreciation for life and meaningful relationships. Embracing these changes, Paul began to explore a pathless path, valuing experiences and connections over conventional success.

How Paul's Ambitious Pursuit Was Derailed by a Health Crisis and Lead to True Fulfillment?

Before Paul's health crisis forced him to take a break from work, like many, he saw full-time employment as a given. However, his illness revealed the fragility of this worldview, leading him to question the centrality of work in our lives. This book emerged from that journey of discovery.

Historian Max Weber noted that capitalism struggled to take root in societies with a "traditionalist" mindset, where people worked only to meet their basic needs. This view can still be seen globally, such as in Mexico, where locals may stop working if paid too much. In contrast, ancient Greek philosophers like Aristotle valued contemplation over the "money-making life," seeing work as a necessary evil.

For centuries, work was primarily a means to meet basic needs, influenced by religious teachings that saw labor as a duty. This changed with the Protestant Reformation, where Martin Luther and John Calvin framed work as a "calling" to honor God. This shift led to an obsession with work in Northern Europe, as described by philosopher Erich Fromm.

The modern work ethic, deeply influenced by these religious views, became ingrained in the post-World War II era, marked by unprecedented economic growth in the United States. This period, known as the "long boom," created an expectation of constant advancement and prosperity.

However, this mindset faced challenges as economic conditions changed. Paul's generation entered the workforce with high expectations, seeking not just employment but meaningful and fulfilling work. Companies like Google set the bar high, offering perks that made work seem fun and purposeful.

Despite these aspirations, studies show that meaningful work often involves overcoming obstacles rather than experiencing unalloyed joy. Sociologist André Gorz described "wage-based societies," where formal work is central to social membership. However, only a minority of adults in the U.S. work full-time, and "nontraditional" employment is on the rise.

This disconnect between expectations and reality is evident in jobs that feel pointless, as detailed in David Graeber's "Bullshit Jobs." Paul's own experiences, from internships to consulting at McKinsey, highlighted the absurdity and inefficiency in many workplaces. Ultimately, his inability to fully commit to a wage-based mentality led him to seek a different path, questioning the central role of work in our lives.

From Aristotle to Google: Rethinking Work in the Modern Era

David Foster Wallace once said, "I think that the ultimate way you and I get lucky is if you have some success early in life, you get to find out early it doesn't mean anything." This resonated deeply with Paul as he reflected on his journey of leaving his full-time job. It wasn't a single bold decision but a slow awakening that the path he was on wasn't truly his.

Like his friend, Khe Hy, who left a successful finance career after enduring a persistent discomfort, Paul too felt a "pebble in his shoe." After returning to work post-health challenges, he became restless and began observing his colleagues with new eyes, questioning if they were happy or fulfilled. Inspired to redesign his career, Paul created a daily reminder of his priorities: health, relationships, fun & creativity, and career. This list, which pops up on his phone every morning, became a commitment to exploring a life not centered around work.

Testing his boundaries led him to a split identity: "Default Path Paul" focused on career advancement, while "Pathless Path Paul" followed creative impulses. Encouraged by a career coach, he started a side gig in coaching, which brought immense joy and a sense of purpose. However, his day job felt increasingly stifling and misaligned with his true self.

Despite his achievements, his motivation dwindled, much like Daniel Vassallo's experience at Amazon. Paul realized intrinsic motivation was the key and began to embrace the "spirit of the fool," diving into new ventures despite uncertainty. Eventually, he admitted to himself and his manager that his heart wasn't in his job. This honesty was a crucial step in letting go of the default path.

A job offer with a significant pay cut became a blessing in disguise, forcing him to confront his attachment to money and self-worth. Inspired by the idea of pairing less income with more freedom, Paul began to imagine a new path. He decided to pursue freelancing, seeking work that aligned with his passions while gaining control over his life.

In this journey, Paul has embraced the creative chaos and uncertainty, continually asking deeper questions and seeking a life that prioritizes health, relationships, and creativity over traditional career success.

Is Following the Pathless Path the Key to True Fulfillment?

Rebecca Solnit once said that some of us need to burn down the house of inherited values to find our own ground and build from scratch. That’s exactly what Paul did when he rejected a job offer and began reflecting on his life. He had a vision from business school of being a leader who embodied empathy, humility, humor, and independence, but he realized he had strayed far from that path. Paul's curiosity had vanished, he was cynical, and he had lost his sense of humor.

A turning point came during a wedding trip in Sarasota, Florida, when Paul impulsively told his manager, “I think it’s time to move on.” This unexpected resignation felt both confusing and liberating. Paul spent the next three months at his job, feeling like part of a faceless blob commuting daily to Manhattan, trapped in a routine that no longer fit him.

On his final day, Paul felt a surge of emotions and began writing. The word “burnout” emerged, a term coined by Herbert Freudenberger in the 1970s to describe the exhaustion faced by dedicated workers under pressure. Paul realized he was experiencing this disconnect between his values and his work culture, leading to cynicism and emotional numbness.

To recover, Paul took a five-week trip to Europe, pushing himself beyond the default settings of his life. An incredible sunset in Florence filled him with joy, but the next day he fell ill, a reminder of the emotional toll of leaving his job. Burnout, as Freudenberger noted, involves mourning the loss of ideals.

Returning to New York without a job was daunting, and Paul threw himself into freelance projects, even holding a sign in Union Square asking about Allbird shoes. This marked a shift from his previous life of formalities. Eventually, Paul moved to Boston and found confidence in his freelance journey.

But deeper questions lingered: “Am I a worker?” Philosopher Andrew Taggart’s challenge to the concept of “total work” made Paul question his identity. He had always measured his worth by his job, but now he embraced a life of leisure and creativity, launching a blog and podcast.

A surprising freelance opportunity arose, allowing Paul to work remotely from Asia. In Bali, he worked from a café on a cliff, marveling at the surfers below. This unconventional life, enabled by the internet, expanded his imagination. If Paul could work from Bali, what other possibilities awaited?

Paul had embarked on the pathless path, embracing uncertainty and exploring a life beyond conventional work. It was a journey of rediscovery, creativity, and endless possibility.

Rebecca Solnit's Wisdom Ignites a Journey from Burnout to Bali Bliss

Embarking on a new journey often comes with uncertainty and fear, but it’s a path worth taking. Joseph Pieper emphasizes that wondering, or acknowledging our un-knowing, propels us forward rather than holding us back. This sentiment is echoed in the stories of people who have taken unconventional paths by prototyping their changes through small, deliberate steps.

Take John Zeratsky, who didn’t just quit his job to sail around Central America but gradually tested this lifestyle with smaller trips over years. Similarly, Diania Merriam discovered the FIRE community, cleared her debt, negotiated remote work, and took a sabbatical to walk the Camino de Santiago before fully embracing self-employment. These stories highlight that significant changes often start with manageable risks, not leaps of blind courage.

Wonder plays a crucial role in tipping the scales toward change. It makes us curious about potential futures and fuels our desire to explore new paths. Michael Ashcroft experienced this when he left his energy sector job to explore different kinds of work, driven by the excitement of unknown possibilities.

Rolf Potts and Gretchen Rubin also illustrate the power of wonder. Potts’ transformative travel experiences and Rubin’s decision to leave law for writing show that embracing wonder can lead to profound life changes. Rubin’s willingness to fail as a writer rather than succeed as a lawyer underscores the importance of pursuing one’s ideal self over societal expectations.

Yet, making such changes is not without its challenges. Facing fears is inevitable. Tim Ferriss’ “fear setting” exercise, which involves writing down worst-case scenarios and possible mitigations, helps manage these fears. Reflecting on potential benefits and the cost of inaction can shift focus from future uncertainties to present realities.

Social support is equally essential. Finding others on similar paths provides inspiration and companionship. Seth Godin’s advice to “find the others” underscores the importance of community. Connecting with people who understand and support your journey can make the pathless path less daunting.

Ultimately, the journey is about learning to see the world in new ways, embracing wonder, and finding the courage to pursue what truly matters. It’s a path filled with uncertainty but also one rich with potential and discovery.

Can Small Steps Lead You to Transform Your Life Like Tim Ferriss and Gretchen Rubin?

In 2018, Paul was boarding a flight to Taipei to start living and working nomadically. Simplifying his life and embracing minimalism has given him more time and less rush to “do things,” allowing him to explore random routes, take city walks, and have unexpected conversations.

Upon arriving in Taipei in fall 2018, Paul found himself in a small Airbnb apartment, starting the coffeemaker and realizing there was nothing urgent to do. He was a 33-year-old, single freelancer without clients, aiming to become a “digital nomad.” He had recently told his friends he was giving up on dating, but just a year later, he was planning a tiny wedding, growing his business, and writing as part of his journey.

Rebecca Solnit's words, "getting lost," resonated with Paul as he navigated Taipei, a place where he couldn’t read the signs or speak the language, yet felt right at home. This contrasted with the tension and anxiety he had felt in New York and Boston over the past ten years. In Taipei, Paul embraced a state of “wu wei” or “non-doing,” a deep connectedness with the world.

Paul's first date with Angie at a tea house in Taipei turned into a series of adventures and deep conversations about life, leading to their falling in love. For years, he had sought someone to “settle down” with, but he was looking within the confines of the default path rather than what he truly wanted. Joseph Campbell's words, “We must let go of the life we have planned, so as to accept the one that is waiting for us,” guided his journey.

Taking a break from work and embracing non-doing helped Paul realize profound shifts in his life and the lives of others like Mohit Satyanand, who moved to a cottage in India to watch the peaches grow and his son toddle. People who took breaks often reported increased life satisfaction, curiosity, and a desire to continue their non-work journey. They also found writing as a significant part of their transformation.

Rethinking retirement, Paul embraced Tim Ferriss’ idea of “mini-retirements,” redistributing periods of rest and exploration throughout life rather than saving them for old age. This approach allowed him to experiment with different ways of living and working, continually crafting a life he was excited to live.

Living without a steady paycheck changed Paul's relationship with money. Inspired by Ramit Sethi’s question, “What is your rich life?” he realized that owning his time enriched his life. Reducing expenses and finding freelance work lowered his financial insecurity, allowing him to focus on what truly mattered.

In Taipei, Paul met Angie, who asked him about his plans for December. Guided by faith and radical acceptance, he decided to join her in Thailand. Faith, as Sharon Salzberg describes, is about exploring the limits and stepping into life’s possibilities. He embraced this uncertainty, knowing that the next steps, though unknown, were part of the journey. He returned to Taiwan to support Angie as she embarked on the next chapter of her life, trusting that everything would be okay.

From Taipei to Thailand: Embracing Life’s Unexpected Journeys

In 2019, Gallup surveyed Americans about their definition of success. An overwhelming 97% said that success means following one's interests and talents to become the best version of oneself. However, these same people believed that others defined success as being rich, having a high-profile career, or achieving fame. This disconnect highlights how society's superficial measures of success overshadow personal fulfillment.

Many people, including professional basketball player Kevin Durant and author Ryan Holiday, have achieved significant milestones only to find themselves feeling empty. This phenomenon, known as the "arrival fallacy," is the false belief that achieving a specific goal will bring lasting happiness. Harvard professor Dr. Ben-Shahar calls this out, emphasizing that true satisfaction comes from the journey, not the destination.

The narrative of "prestige" often drives people to pursue status symbols like high-paying jobs or elite degrees. But as Paul Graham and Sarah Kendzior argue, these "bad tests" measure success based on external validation rather than genuine fulfillment. This realization led many, including Paul, to seek an alternative path—called the "pathless path."

The pathless path is about redefining success on one's own terms. For Paul, this meant leaving a high-status job at McKinsey to pursue writing and freelancing. It wasn't easy, but it was liberating. He found a supportive community online and realized that true prestige comes from helping others and sharing knowledge, not from impressive titles or credentials.

On this path, finding your "tribe" is crucial. The internet has enabled the formation of micro-communities where people can connect based on shared values and interests. These communities provide a sense of belonging and support, encouraging members to pursue their unique paths.

Embracing the pathless path often means grappling with feelings of being a "bad egg" in a world that values conformity. But as Thoreau once wrote, "Not till we are lost, in other words, not till we have lost the world, do we begin to find ourselves." On this journey, learning to define "enough" is essential. For Paul, "enough" means having sufficient resources to live comfortably without excess.

Ultimately, the pathless path is about living a life that feels heroic, as anthropologist Ernest Becker suggests. It's a journey of self-discovery, grappling with insecurities, and daring to seek out a life that is uniquely yours. The opportunities are infinite, and the rewards are far more fulfilling than any external measure of success.

Is Kevin Durant's Arrival Fallacy Proof That True Success Lies Beyond Fame and Fortune?

There’s so much more to who you are than you know right now. You hold within you a great gift for this world. Bill Plotkin encourages us to discover our true selves and embrace a life of fulfillment and service. 

David Whyte talks about the "conversational nature of reality," suggesting that life is an ongoing dialogue with the world. By asking questions driven by curiosity, we can discover our true passions. For example, when Paul quit his job, he wandered New York and ended up at a park called the Cloisters. He felt lost but kept going, unknowingly heading towards a future far from what he had imagined.

John O’Nolan, founder of the blogging platform Ghost, teaches us to build something we love rather than chasing success. He turned down high-maintenance clients to stay true to his vision, showing that saying "no" to obvious opportunities can lead to fulfilling work.

Stephen Cope’s book "The Great Work of Your Life" explores the importance of finding work that brings you alive. He studied lives of people like Susan Anthony and Henry David Thoreau, who faced challenges but stayed true to their passions. This pursuit, he argues, is the real work of life.

Robert Kegan highlights the shift towards "self-authoring," where we create our own life narratives. Brene Brown’s distinction between shame and guilt helps us understand our motivations. Guilt, unlike shame, can guide us towards what we value.

Feeling useful is a profound human need. Sebastian Junger found that soldiers, despite PTSD, wanted to return to war zones because they felt necessary there. Finding work that aligns with what matters to you makes you feel useful and opens up the world.

Creativity is an act of navigating without a map, says Seth Godin. We all have it, whether in parenting, planning a wedding, or learning technology. The internet has removed gatekeepers, allowing us to share our creativity freely. Paul's writing journey began on Quora, where sharing his vulnerabilities led to unexpected connections and support.

Figuring out who you want to serve is crucial. Seth Godin’s story about David Chang illustrates the importance of focusing on your true audience. On the pathless path, finding the right people to support you can boost your confidence and courage.

Maria Popova introduced Paul to the idea that "critical thinking without hope is cynicism." Initially, his writings were driven by frustration but lacked inspiration. Injecting hope transformed his work and attracted the kind of people he wanted to engage with.

Embracing your curiosity, vulnerability, and passion can lead to a virtuous cycle of work and life. Cynicism is a dangerous failure mode, but hope can sustain a fulfilling journey. When Paul opened his heart, he received more support, leading to a more exciting future.

Unlock Your Potential: Wisdom from Bill Plotkin, David Whyte, and More

When Anna Quindlen quit the New York Times to be a full-time mother, then to become a novelist, people thought she was crazy. Yet, she found happiness and success on her own terms. This story highlights the importance of defining success by what feels right in your heart, not by the world's standards. 

The "pathless path" invites us to explore vast possibilities without predefined limits. Instead of endlessly searching for the perfect path, look at what you don’t want to be doing and work backward to avoid pitfalls. This concept, known as inversion, helps identify traps that could derail your journey.

Paul Millerd, once on a traditional career path, now embraces the pathless path, seeking a life rich in experiences and diverse income streams. He adopted the principle of antifragility, building resilience by generating income from multiple sources. This approach ensures that even if one source fails, others sustain him.

Exploring freedom, Paul references Erich Fromm’s distinction between "freedom from" and "freedom to." True freedom involves engaging in creative activities that connect us deeply with the world. This mindset led Paul to practice generosity as a skill, embracing a gift economy to foster meaningful connections and abundance.

From the story of Morrie Schwartz, who created his own culture of human connection and purpose despite his terminal illness, Paul draws inspiration to live a life filled with passion and purpose. Morrie's advice to "create your own culture" resonates deeply, encouraging us to craft lives true to our values.

Paul’s journey emphasizes experimenting with life, making friends, creating, giving generously, and committing to what matters. He shares practical steps to embrace the pathless path, urging us to question the default, reflect, offer our unique gifts, pause, and disconnect. 

Ultimately, the pathless path is about finding joy in the journey, seeking a life that makes you come alive rather than just getting ahead. Embrace change, practice patience, and dare to explore your one wild and precious life.

Is Anna Quindlen's Pathless Path the Secret to True Happiness and Success?

In his journey, Paul has come to realize that ambition can become a trap that leads us away from genuine curiosity and fulfillment. His own path has been marked by a shift from pursuing conventional success to seeking a life rich in experiences and personal connections. The health crisis he faced was a wake-up call, prompting him to question his life's purpose and the centrality of work.

Crises often lead to profound personal growth, as they force us to reevaluate our priorities and embrace deeper values. This shift in perspective made Paul appreciate life's simpler joys and meaningful relationships over career achievements. He found that true satisfaction comes not from relentless work but from a balanced life where health, relationships, creativity, and fun are prioritized.

The traditional work ethic, deeply rooted in religious teachings and the capitalist mindset, has shaped our societal norms. However, economic changes and personal experiences have led many, including Paul, to question the central role of work. The rise of the gig economy and nontraditional employment reflects a growing desire for more meaningful and flexible ways of living.

Embracing the "pathless path" means redefining success on one's own terms, often through small, deliberate steps rather than bold leaps. For Paul, this journey is about curiosity, creativity, and the courage to pursue what truly matters, supported by a community of like-minded individuals.

Living without a steady paycheck has changed Paul's relationship with money, focusing on owning his time and reducing financial insecurity. His path has also involved exploring different ways of living and working, guided by faith and an openness to life's possibilities.

Ultimately, the pathless path is about finding joy in the journey, seeking a life that makes you come alive rather than just getting ahead. For Paul, it's a continuous process of self-discovery, embracing wonder, and daring to explore a life beyond conventional definitions of success.

Home

Trending Books

News & Mags

Relax

Curated

Collections

Key Ideas & Notes

Insights

Highlights & Bookmarks

Listening History

The Pathless Path: Imagining a New Story For Work and Life

Paul Millerd

Are you ready to redefine success on your own terms?

Do you want to trade traditional work ethics and societal norms for a life that brings you pure joy and fulfillment?

What if you could follow the pathless path, prioritizing health, relationships, creativity, and fun over career achievements?

Dive into this transformative journey of a former McKinsey consultant as he grapples with personal crises, embraces change, and dares to explore a life beyond conventional definitions of success.

Key Ideas

#1