Ever wondered how a Silicon Valley high-tech marketer found fulfillment in the straightforward world of construction? Intrigued how a successful startup co-founder used the principles of teamwork to transform a traditional building company? Curious about the fictional journey of Jeff Shanley, who swapped pretentiousness for humility, hunger, and people smarts? Want to know the secret behind Valley Builders' soaring success and the role played by the virtues of an ideal team player? Dive into this fictional story and find out!

The Ideal Team Player: How to Recognize and Cultivate The Three Essential Virtues

After twenty years in Silicon Valley, Jeff Shanley had had enough. The hours, traffic, and pretentiousness had worn thin. 

Despite an interesting and successful career in high-tech marketing and co-founding a startup, Jeff craved change. His pivotal mentor, CEO Kathryn Petersen, taught him invaluable lessons in leadership and teamwork. Later, working at a consulting firm in Half Moon Bay, Jeff and his wife grew weary of keeping up with their affluent neighbors.

Unexpectedly, Jeff's uncle Bob, a prominent building contractor in Napa Valley, called seeking advice on finding a successor for his thriving business. Bob's children had chosen different career paths, leaving the future of Valley Builders uncertain. Jeff had helped Bob with teamwork projects before, earning high praise and the affectionate title of "best advisor" from his uncle.

Surprising both himself and Bob, Jeff expressed interest in running the company despite his lack of industry experience. Within a month, Jeff and his family relocated to Napa, where he faced a four-mile, seven-minute commute to his new job. 

Initially, Jeff felt remorse as he grappled with the tangible, straightforward nature of construction work, a stark contrast to the theoretical debates of high tech. However, he soon found these clear-cut conversations more gratifying. 

Learning from his uncle, who despite lacking formal education had a profound understanding of business, Jeff realized he had made the right move. The simplicity and directness of construction work proved to be a refreshing change from the stress of Silicon Valley. But as Jeff settled in, he was about to discover that his new life held its own unexpected challenges.

Can Jeff Shanley Trade Silicon Valley's Glitz for Napa Valley's Grit?

Bob Shanley, a bold and decisive leader, had built Valley Builders (VB) into a thriving company. With over 200 employees and several family members as private shareholders, VB was a cornerstone of the local economy. Bob’s nephew, Jeff, had recently joined the firm, learning the ropes of construction operations.

One day, during lunch at a BBQ restaurant, Bob dropped a bombshell. He revealed that he had a serious heart condition requiring immediate surgery, meaning he would need to step away from the business right away. Despite Jeff's protests about his readiness, Bob insisted he take over immediately, citing a need for urgency.

As they discussed the company's financial health, Bob shared exciting yet daunting news: VB had landed two major projects simultaneously, the Queen of the Valley Hospital and a new hotel in St. Helena. Jeff, stunned by the enormity of the task, suggested focusing on one project, but Bob explained that backing out wasn’t an option due to financial commitments.

After lunch, Jeff met with Clare Massick and Bobby Brady, senior executives at VB. Initially, the meeting took a dramatic turn as they pranked Jeff, pretending to be displeased with his promotion. However, they eventually assured Jeff of their support. Clare and Bobby clarified they had no desire for the CEO role and believed Jeff was the best person for the job due to his familiarity with the company and its people.

Despite the daunting challenges ahead, Jeff felt a renewed sense of confidence with Clare and Bobby's backing. The trio prepared to face the future together, united in their commitment to keep Valley Builders thriving.

Bob Shanley’s Bold Move: Heart Surgery Hands Reins to Nephew Jeff Amid Major Projects

Jeff sat down with his new team at Maria's Mexican Restaurant, a quiet spot despite the mediocre food. "Let's identify the biggest levers we need to pull," he began. 

Bobby and Clare hesitated until Jeff clarified, "Big categories like financing, labor, materials." They both agreed labor was critical. Bobby estimated needing sixty new hires in two months, which Clare adjusted to eighty to account for turnover. They discussed specific roles needed and then shifted to other project details. Jeff felt he learned more in those three hours than his first sixty days on the job.

On his drive home, Jeff spoke with his cousin Ben, a high school coach and teacher. Ben was supportive and offered to help, though he admitted he didn’t know much about the business. Jeff appreciated Ben’s optimism but worried about the challenges ahead.

At home, Jeff's wife, Maurine, was surprisingly positive about his new responsibilities. "You need a challenge," she said, believing the work would suit him despite his concerns about its impact on family relationships. Jeff knew she was right and decided to tackle one issue at a time.

The next morning, Jeff visited the Oak Ridge building site. He learned that foremen had quit due to a toxic work environment. Nancy Morris, a project manager, admitted to strained relations with Craig, another manager. Craig confirmed the tension, calling Nancy difficult to work with. Jeff realized deeper issues in the company culture and knew they needed to address them.

Jeff sought insights from administrative employees over lunch. They spoke well of the hiring process but Jeff noted a disconnect in identifying true team players. Returning to the office, he shared his concerns with Bobby and Clare, emphasizing the need to define and identify real team-oriented behaviors.

Jeff’s journey in construction management had just begun, marked by a steep learning curve and a pressing need to foster genuine teamwork. His resolve to tackle problems one at a time gave him a sense of direction, even if the path ahead was fraught with challenges.

Can Jeff Transform a Struggling Team into a Cohesive Success?

Jeff was adamant about teamwork being the cornerstone of their company’s success. "This teamwork thing is key," Jeff declared before anyone sat down.

Bobby quickly agreed, suggesting they ramp up recruitment efforts. But Jeff was skeptical about hiring eighty new people. "We hired thirty last year and had turnover," he reminded them. Clare nodded, acknowledging that doubling hires would likely worsen their ability to find the right team players. Bobby proposed lowering standards, but Clare objected. "That’s what caused problems like the Oak Ridge and school renovation fiascos," she said, recalling how retaining poor team players led to losing their best engineer.

Jeff insisted on maintaining high standards, arguing that fewer but better team players would yield greater productivity. He emphasized the need for honesty, accountability, and commitment among employees. Clare and Bobby hesitated but ultimately agreed.

Reflecting on past hires, Clare and Bobby realized they allowed poor team players to hire more like themselves. Jeff highlighted the importance of addressing this issue. “The most unhappy people are those who don’t fit the culture,” he explained, advocating for identifying and transforming or replacing such employees.

They pondered over their own suitability as team players. Jeff encouraged self-assessment, prompting Bobby to recall Bob's humility and fairness, traits that made him a beloved leader. Jeff and Clare agreed these qualities were essential for all team members.

In a meeting with Ben, a high school basketball coach, Jeff sought insights into identifying good team players. Ben valued players who were dedicated, cooperative, and hated losing with a passion, traits he believed were crucial for team success.

Back at work, Jeff asked Clare to list all former employees let go or underperforming. They analyzed these cases, identifying traits like negativity, laziness, and irresponsibility. Jeff noted the simplicity of the findings but insisted on deeper analysis.

As they faced massive new projects, Jeff realized they needed more help. Bobby suggested Ted Marchbanks, a retired executive with vast experience. They met Ted and found him capable and personable. However, Clare and Jeff wanted to ensure he wasn't a "jackass."

They discussed what made someone a poor team player, citing specific examples. Jeff summarized the essential qualities as unpretentiousness, hard work, and people skills. Clare agreed, finding the simplicity revealing.

With pressing meetings ahead, they decided to continue refining their approach to building the right team. As they left, the clarity of their mission began to take shape: identifying and fostering genuine team players to drive the company’s success.

Jeff's Secret to Success: The Power of Teamwork and High Standards

Things were hectic at Oak Ridge, and Bobby had to be there to manage the inspectors. Meanwhile, Bob's surgery went well, and the office felt relieved, but their focus quickly shifted back to business. They rescheduled Ted's follow-up interview and decided to refine their idea of a team player.

That evening, Clare, Jeff, and Bobby gathered over Indian food to finalize their team player criteria. They discussed past employees like Tommy Burleson, who was charming but not passionate about work. They settled on three key traits: humble, hungry, and smart.

The next day, Ted's comprehensive interview began. Jeff briefed Craig, the foreman, on evaluating Ted's hunger and humility. After Craig's interview, he reported that Ted seemed eager but wasn't sure about his humility. Clare then took Ted on an errand to observe him in a casual setting. Ted handled it well but didn't leave a strong impression of humility.

Later, Kim, the receptionist, shared that Ted hadn't engaged with her. This raised concerns about his humility. Jeff's lunch with Ted confirmed his doubts. Ted's responses seemed generic, and he didn't send references as promised.

In a surprising turn, Ted called Jeff to withdraw from the process, citing second thoughts about leaving retirement. Jeff felt relieved but worried about the firm's hiring needs. Clare and Bobby were disappointed but discussed promoting Craig, who fit their team player model perfectly.

They also addressed Nancy, who was hardworking but lacked people skills. Jeff proposed a direct conversation to see if she was willing to improve. They concluded that genuine willingness to change was crucial for development.

Ultimately, the team decided to trust their humble, hungry, and smart criteria, confident it would guide them in building a strong, cohesive team.

Can Humble, Hungry, and Smart Be the Ultimate Formula for Team Success?

Nancy walked into Jeff's office, a little unsure of what to expect. Jeff, sensing her tension, had asked her to clear her schedule. He aimed to discuss her future at VB and her openness to change. 

As they settled into their conversation, Jeff emphasized the company's focus on teamwork and introduced the attributes of an ideal team player: humble, hungry, and smart. Nancy admitted her strengths and weaknesses, noting her lack of social awareness but expressed willingness to improve.

About a week later, Jeff confirmed Craig's hiring, following an overwhelmingly positive response from employees. They had dodged a bullet by not hiring Ted Marchbanks, based on some candid feedback from his former colleagues. 

Within a month, VB's environment had transformed. The new hiring model focusing on humble, hungry, and smart employees was paying off. Every new hire fit the bill, and those who didn’t, left voluntarily. Jeff even re-interviewed all foremen to ensure alignment with the new values, offering support for those who needed improvement.

Six months in, while the projects at the hospital and hotel faced typical challenges, Jeff was reassured by the team’s progress. Though not perfect, they were moving in the right direction, thanks to the new cultural model. A year later, the company had seen substantial improvements. Bob, now retired, occasionally visited, always with a positive outlook. Craig had become an indispensable part of the executive team, and the company culture deeply embraced the virtues of humility, hunger, and intelligence. 

The impact was clear. Recruitment was now driven by employee referrals, morale was higher, turnover was lower, and client satisfaction had soared. Bobby, reflecting on the changes, humorously noted that VB had nearly become a "jackass-free zone," a sentiment captured on a T-shirt he gave to Jeff—a reminder of the company's commitment to its core values.

How Jeff's Leadership Transformed VB into a 'Jackass-Free Zone'

The essential virtues that make up an exceptional team member are humility, hunger, and people smarts. These virtues are crucial for anyone who wants to contribute effectively to a team's success.

Humility is the most critical virtue. Humble team players lack excessive ego, emphasize team success over individual accolades, and are quick to share credit. They avoid arrogance and are self-aware enough to recognize and value their own contributions without overshadowing those of others. C.S. Lewis aptly said, "Humility isn't thinking less of yourself, but thinking of yourself less," capturing the essence of this virtue.

Hunger refers to a person's intrinsic motivation and relentless pursuit of improvement. Hungry team players are always looking for more responsibilities and ways to contribute, driven by a sense of duty and passion for their work. However, it's important for this hunger to be directed towards the team's success rather than personal gain.

People Smarts is about interpersonal intelligence. Team players who are smart in this way can navigate group dynamics effectively, understanding the impact of their words and actions on their colleagues. They demonstrate good judgment and empathy, making them adept at managing relationships within the team.

While each of these virtues is important on its own, the combination of all three is what makes an ideal team player. Missing even one virtue can significantly hinder team effectiveness. For instance, someone who is humble and hungry but lacks people smarts can unintentionally create interpersonal problems, while someone who is hungry and smart but not humble may manipulate the team for personal gain.

The model's origin story is equally compelling. Lencioni, the author, and his colleagues at The Table Group, a management consulting firm, initially adopted these virtues as their core values. Over time, they realized that their focus on humility, hunger, and people smarts resonated deeply with their clients, many of whom wanted to adopt these values for their own organizations.

The book also provides practical applications of the model, including hiring, assessing current employees, and developing those who lack one or more of these virtues. Lencioni emphasizes the importance of embedding these virtues into the organizational culture, advocating for explicit and bold communication about these values to employees, vendors, partners, and customers.

By fostering a culture that prizes humility, hunger, and people smarts, leaders can ensure that their teams are composed of individuals who not only perform well but also enhance the overall team dynamic. This alignment not only boosts productivity but also creates a more cohesive, supportive, and ultimately more successful team.

Can Patrick Lencioni's Ideal Team Player Virtues Transform Your Organization?

After two decades in the hectic world of Silicon Valley, Jeff Shanley yearned for a simpler life. Despite a successful career in high-tech marketing and co-founding a startup, the relentless pace and superficiality of the Valley left him craving change. 

A call from his uncle Bob, a prominent building contractor in Napa Valley, presented an unexpected opportunity. Bob needed a successor for his thriving business, Valley Builders (VB), as his own children had chosen different paths. Despite having no experience in construction, Jeff expressed interest in taking over.

Jeff and his family moved to Napa, where he faced a short, stress-free commute to his new job. Initially, he struggled with the direct, tangible nature of construction work, having been accustomed to the theoretical debates of high tech. However, he found satisfaction in the straightforwardness of his new role.

One day, during a lunch at a BBQ restaurant, Bob revealed he had a serious heart condition requiring immediate surgery and insisted Jeff take over the company right away. Though overwhelmed, Jeff found confidence in the support of senior executives Clare Massick and Bobby Brady. They assured him of their backing, believing in his ability to lead VB.

Jeff soon discovered deeper issues within the company culture, particularly at the Oak Ridge building site, where foremen had quit due to a toxic environment. Determined to address these challenges, Jeff emphasized the importance of teamwork and the need to hire employees who were humble, hungry, and smart—qualities he deemed essential for success.

Over time, this hiring model transformed VB’s environment. The company saw substantial improvements in morale, turnover, and client satisfaction. The simplicity and directness of the construction industry, paired with a strong focus on genuine teamwork, proved to be a refreshing and fulfilling change for Jeff. 

Jeff’s journey, marked by a steep learning curve and a pressing need to foster genuine teamwork, highlighted the significance of humility, hunger, and people smarts. By embedding these virtues into the organizational culture, he ensured that VB not only thrived but also became a cohesive, supportive team. Reflecting on the transformation, Jeff realized the profound impact of these core values on both the company’s success and his personal fulfillment.

Home

Trending Books

News & Mags

Relax

Curated

Collections

Key Ideas & Notes

Insights

Highlights & Bookmarks

Listening History

The Ideal Team Player: How to Recognize and Cultivate The Three Essential Virtues

Patrick Lencioni

Ever wondered how a Silicon Valley high-tech marketer found fulfillment in the straightforward world of construction?

Intrigued how a successful startup co-founder used the principles of teamwork to transform a traditional building company?

Curious about the fictional journey of Jeff Shanley, who swapped pretentiousness for humility, hunger, and people smarts?

Want to know the secret behind Valley Builders' soaring success and the role played by the virtues of an ideal team player?

Dive into this fictional story and find out!

Key Ideas

#1