What if happiness isn’t a straight path, but a curve? From Andrew Sullivan’s midlife epiphany to Andrew Oswald’s discovery of a U-shaped happiness trajectory—even shared by great apes—this journey challenges everything we think we know about fulfillment. Could the midlife dip actually be the springboard to wisdom, connection, and a richer second act? Dive in and decide for yourself!

The Happiness Curve: Why Life Gets Better After 50

Karl, a 45-year-old professional, navigates life's ups and downs, reflecting on the unexpected dissatisfaction he feels despite his outward success. Like many, his twenties were wild and free, but responsibility in his thirties brought predictability. 

Though his career and family life flourished, he found himself yearning for change. He switched jobs seeking fulfillment but still felt lost, a sentiment shared by Dominic, a peer who also shifted paths in search of meaning. Dominic eventually found gratitude and appreciation in life's ordinary moments, sparking a shift in perspective.

Karl's story echoes the timeless struggle captured by Thomas Cole's paintings, "The Voyage of Life," which depict life's stages from childhood to old age. Cole's art, like Karl's journey, explores the tumultuous middle age when dreams meet reality and dissatisfaction creeps in. This period, research reveals, isn't unique to Karl—it’s a natural phase, a dip in the happiness curve that many experience.

The curve, studied by economists and psychologists, shows a midlife trough in happiness followed by an unexpected upturn in later years. This transformation isn't just about mood; it's a shift in values, leading to greater contentment and wisdom. Society’s understanding of this curve can help us navigate midlife challenges and embrace the encore adulthood—a stage of life rich with potential for connection and compassion.

Karl's narrative invites us to reconsider our assumptions about happiness and aging, urging us to embrace life's transitions with grace and to support each other through the midlife trough. It’s a journey not just of personal discovery but of collective growth, reshaping how we view the latter half of life.

Can Karl's Midlife Crisis Teach Us the Secret to True Happiness?

Meet Carol Graham, an economist whose life story is a testament to the enigmatic nature of happiness. Despite facing a tumultuous period in her forties—separation, parental illnesses, and career challenges—Graham produced some of her most impactful work, including a book that delves into the paradox of happiness across different economic strata. Her research uncovered a curious phenomenon: people in rapidly growing economies often report lower life satisfaction, despite improved material conditions.

This paradox, echoing the Easterlin Paradox, challenges the assumption that increased wealth equates to increased happiness. As Graham's findings show, happiness is not solely tied to material gains; it's a complex interplay of social and relational factors. Her insights reveal that beyond a certain point, money matters less compared to relationships, trust, and social support. These findings resonate with Aristotle's teachings that deeper satisfaction emerges from virtuous living and social bonds.

Graham's journey reflects this wisdom. As she moved past her forties, she found fulfillment not just in her professional successes but also in personal growth and relationships. Her story illustrates the happiness curve, a pattern where life satisfaction dips in midlife but rises thereafter, offering hope and perspective in understanding the complexities of happiness. It’s a narrative that challenges us to rethink our priorities, valuing social wealth over material gain, and embracing the unpredictable yet enriching journey toward happiness.

Carol Graham's Happiness Paradox: Wealth vs. Well-being in a Rapidly Changing World

In the realm of human emotions, the concept of a midlife crisis has intrigued and baffled experts and laypeople alike. Originally coined by psychoanalyst Elliott Jaques in 1965, the idea suggested a unique turmoil faced by individuals as they grapple with the reality of aging and unfulfilled dreams. Despite its popularity in culture, psychologists found little scientific evidence to support the universality of a midlife crisis.

However, a different narrative began to unfold thanks to Andrew Oswald and David Blanchflower, two economists with a penchant for exploring happiness through data. Their research highlighted a recurring U-shaped curve in life satisfaction, with a dip in middle age followed by an upswing in later years. This pattern appeared consistently across various countries and demographics, suggesting a universal trend rather than a mere cultural phenomenon.

What made this discovery particularly intriguing was its validation beyond human subjects. Oswald's collaboration with psychologist Alex Weiss revealed that great apes exhibited a similar U-shape in wellbeing, hinting at a biological underpinning shared across primate species. This groundbreaking research challenged the notion of midlife crisis as purely cultural, suggesting it might be woven into our biology.

The personal stories of Oswald and Blanchflower themselves echoed the data. Both experienced significant life changes and challenges in their forties but found renewed happiness and perspective as they aged. Their research and personal journeys underscore the complex interplay of biology, psychology, and life circumstances, offering a hopeful outlook that tranquility often awaits beyond the midlife dip.

So, while the midlife crisis might not be a universal experience, the happiness curve suggests that many will eventually find peace and growth as they move past middle age. As Oswald optimistically remarked, "Just wait until you're sixty!"

Is the Midlife Crisis More Than Just a Cultural Myth, According to Economists Oswald and Blanchflower?

In the winding journey of life, happiness takes on varied shapes and curves, much like the unpredictable flow of a river. The notion of a universal midlife crisis is debunked as a myth; instead, psychologists suggest change is possible at any age as people strive for fulfillment. 

Some experience a U-shaped happiness curve, where satisfaction dips in middle age only to rise later, while others follow an upward trajectory, like Joe, who rose from a turbulent youth to find joy in family and stable work by his fifties. On the other hand, Tony's life took a V-shaped turn, marked by a crisis that led to self-destruction and ultimately, recovery. Alan's experience represents a cautionary tale of a U curve gone awry, leaving him with regrets and a lifetime of consequences after a midlife mistake.

The happiness curve, while not a guaranteed path for everyone, casts a subtle undertow that can make midlife more challenging, although not insurmountable. It’s like rowing against a current—you can still navigate successfully if your circumstances, voluntary choices, and resilience align favorably. Studies worldwide support the existence of the happiness curve, showing that age itself has a noticeable effect on life satisfaction. This phenomenon appears to be both biological and influenced by societal factors, as happiness levels and trajectories vary across cultures and countries.

The author posits a revised happiness formula, H = S + C + V + T, where time (T) influences happiness alongside set range (S), circumstances (C), and voluntary choices (V). This formula acknowledges that while age matters, it isn't the sole determinant of happiness. Ultimately, understanding and adapting to the effects of time can help individuals navigate life's currents more smoothly, fostering a more nuanced appreciation of the journey through different ages.

In essence, while time and aging are inevitable, understanding their influence on happiness can help individuals adapt and find fulfillment at every stage of life. By acknowledging the impact of age on happiness, people can better navigate the river of life, perhaps steering toward smoother waters as they grow older and wiser.

Navigating the Happiness Curve: Myths, Realities, and Life's Flow

At 46, Anthony believes he's peaked, with his best days behind him. This sense of midlife malaise often stems from the deceptive happiness curve, which creates discontent from seemingly thin air. 

Anthony's journey through life reflects typical ups and downs: exhilarating twenties marked by independence and growth, challenging thirties filled with job struggles and personal loss, and stagnant forties where he feels he's reached his limits. Despite rating his life satisfaction an eight, the same as in his thirties, Anthony lacks optimism about the future.

Enter Hannes Schwandt, a German economist whose research challenges Anthony's outlook. Schwandt's study reveals a pattern where people consistently overestimate their future life satisfaction, leading to disappointment in middle age. Yet, as expectations lower, the satisfaction curve swings upward in the fifties, bringing pleasant surprises and renewed contentment.

Schwandt's findings suggest that the midlife slump isn't a crisis but a gradual adjustment of expectations, often exacerbated by the feedback effect—feeling dissatisfied about feeling dissatisfied. Anthony's experience embodies this trap, as his achievements don't match his youthful expectations, leading him to believe the best is behind him.

Psychologist Jonathan Haidt offers another perspective, likening the mind to a rider atop an elephant. The elephant's mission isn't happiness but success, constantly recalibrating goals and demanding progress. This aligns with Schwandt's research, where optimism bias diminishes in middle age, leaving room for realistic recalibration.

As the happiness curve bends upward, the realization dawns: life gets better beyond midlife. Anthony, like many others, may find that his emotional peak is yet to come, as the spiral of disappointment reverses and satisfaction grows with unexpected joy in the later years.

Could Anthony's Midlife Crisis Actually Be the Start of His Happiest Years?

Laura Carstensen's journey is a testament to the unexpected twists life can take. In her twenties, after surviving a car accident with twenty-one broken bones, she found herself in an orthopedic ward, bored and contemplating her life choices. Her father suggested she audit a psychology course by listening to lectures on tape, sparking her curiosity about aging and happiness. This curiosity eventually led her to become a leading expert in the field, challenging conventional wisdom that old age is a time of decline.

Her research revealed a surprising truth: older people are often happier than younger ones, despite societal assumptions to the contrary. Carstensen discovered that as people age, they become more selective in their relationships, focusing on those that bring emotional fulfillment rather than seeking new acquaintances. This socioemotional selectivity theory suggests that as our time horizon shortens, our priorities shift towards emotional connectedness and meaningful social interactions.

Carstensen's journey is paralleled by many others who find unexpected satisfaction in their later years. Her father, who feared aging, found peace and happiness in retirement, shedding stress and anger as he focused on what truly mattered. Similarly, others have reported higher life satisfaction in their sixties and seventies, describing these decades with words like "happy," "satisfied," and "content."

Scientific research supports these anecdotes, showing that stress declines after fifty, emotional regulation improves, and older people experience less regret and depression than expected. Studies across the globe confirm this positivity effect, indicating that aging can enhance emotional wellbeing despite physical decline.

Carstensen's work challenges us to rethink aging. Rather than viewing it as a time of sadness and loss, she suggests it offers a chance to focus on what truly matters. By adjusting our cultural narrative to embrace the emotional richness of old age, we might even find ourselves looking forward to getting older.

In her sixties, Carstensen herself found peace and happiness, no longer feeling the pressure to prove herself. Her story, and those of others like her, reveal the paradox of aging: as our bodies change, our values shift, allowing us to savor life's sweetness. Perhaps the secret to happiness as we age lies in accepting life's changing priorities and focusing on the relationships and experiences that bring us joy.

Laura Carstensen's Paradox: Happiness Unveiled in Aging

In 2015, renowned blogger Andrew Sullivan shut down his popular site, The Daily Dish, at the height of his success. At 51, Sullivan realized his ambition-driven life had neglected real connections with friends and family. His story echoes a broader narrative of midlife transition, where individuals reassess their values, moving from ambition to connection. 

Elliott Jaques, who introduced the concept of midlife crisis, described this period as an opportunity for deeper awareness and genuine values. Sullivan, like many others, found happiness in prioritizing relationships over worldly achievements.

Similarly, Paul, a professor and avid rock climber, faced a personal crisis in his forties despite outward success. His journey involved shattered ambitions and a reevaluation of his life's purpose, ultimately finding fulfillment in service to others on Native American reservations. His story illustrates how the happiness curve redirects us toward community and wisdom, not just personal achievements.

The narrative of the happiness curve is enriched by scientific explorations into wisdom. Dilip Jeste, a psychiatrist, suggests that wisdom, a universally recognized trait, might have biological and evolutionary roots. Wisdom is not simply intelligence; it’s a balanced integration of empathy, reflection, and pragmatic knowledge, contributing to better individual and collective wellbeing.

As people age, they often experience a shift in priorities—from seeking status to cultivating deeper connections and wisdom. This transformation is illustrated in stories like Christine's, who found satisfaction in saving a corner of the world rather than pursuing grand ambitions, and David's, who shifted from entrepreneurial success to mentoring others.

The happiness curve, with its midlife dip followed by a rise, serves a social purpose: it encourages a shift from individual ambition to communal values. Wisdom, which grows with age, enriches life by fostering understanding, compassion, and social harmony. This journey, as depicted by Thomas Cole’s river in "The Voyage of Life," is a collective one, shaped by interactions with others, ultimately leading to a richer, more satisfying perspective on life.

Is Midlife Crisis the Secret Path to True Happiness and Wisdom?

A year after Jonathan Rauch's initial interview with Karl, they met again for lunch. He was still in the throes of a midlife slump at 46, feeling trapped and disillusioned despite apparent blessings. Jonathan had shared with him the concept of the "happiness curve" and Hannes Schwandt's research, which illustrates how midlife combines disappointment from past experiences with declining optimism for the future. 

Karl recognized his situation in this model and expressed despair over unmet expectations in his marriage and career. Despite understanding that relief might come with time, Karl's emotional turmoil persisted.

Joshua Coleman, a psychologist, has traversed this midlife trough and emerged with serenity, emphasizing acceptance and the importance of foregrounding positive aspects. His insights reveal that many in their forties experience a malaise driven by unmet expectations and social comparisons, rather than a full-blown crisis. The hedonic treadmill, the endless pursuit of success and status that never truly satisfies, often exacerbates this slump.

Coleman advises normalizing these feelings, helping people see their dissatisfaction as a normal developmental stage rather than a personal failure. This approach can interrupt the negative feedback loop that amplifies discontent. He also highlights the need to manage expectations and accept disappointment as a natural part of life.

In Jonathan's own experience, interrupting internal critics helped ease his self-criticism. Cognitive therapy techniques like the mantra "No comparison!" disrupted negative thought patterns. Staying present, through mindfulness practices, also proved beneficial—reducing anxiety and fostering acceptance.

Sharing struggles, rather than isolating, is crucial. Terry, another interviewee, found solace in friendships that held him accountable and grounded during his midlife identity shift. Professional counseling offers systematic support, but even casual friendships can provide vital emotional stability.

When contemplating change, it's important to step wisely rather than leap impulsively. Incremental and integrative adjustments honor past choices and accumulated skills, reducing the risk of costly mistakes. Barb, a teacher who transitioned to life abroad at 51, exemplifies this approach. Her move was dramatic yet carefully timed and grounded in continuity.

Ultimately, patience is key. While the happiness curve's trough is challenging, it represents a healthy transition. The best way out is often through, with time easing the passage. Waiting is not passive; it's a strategy to let time work for us. As Jonathan discovered, patience was the most effective measure during his forties, particularly when not waiting alone.

Navigating Midlife: Wisdom from Karl, Schwandt, and Coleman

Midlife can feel like a lonely journey, but the truth is, we are all navigating this turbulent sea together. Karl and others like him are not broken; they are experiencing a perfectly normal transition. 

Self-help is valuable, but it’s not enough. We need a supportive environment, social channels, and a narrative that acknowledges this phase as ordinary and nonpathological, much like adolescence. Gary, a professional acquaintance, highlighted the need for mentors and safe spaces to share vulnerabilities without fear of judgment. Instead of medicalizing or mocking midlife malaise, we should foster understanding and support.

Historically, society has adapted to developmental needs, like creating adolescence as a recognized stage. Marc Freedman envisions a new stage, encore adulthood, where people can find purpose and redefine their careers. Prototypes like Stanford’s Distinguished Careers Institute and Leo Burnett’s in-house coaching offer glimpses of how institutions can support midlife transitions. At Leo Burnett, coaching is normalized, helping employees align their values with their work, turning midlife questioning into a career asset.

Social change is coming, driven by baby boomers redefining retirement and work. Programs like The Transition Network and AARP’s Life Reimagined are paving the way, offering peer support and resources for navigating new life phases. This grassroots movement is carving new channels for midlife transitions, much like the creation of adolescence.

Gratitude, as Donald Richie noted, grows with age. It’s a healthy, virtuous, indispensable part of life. In Jonathan's own journey, he has found that gratitude comes more easily as the critics’ voices have faded. 

The happiness curve is a hidden gift, promising relief and renewed appreciation for life. As Karl wrote, knowing he wasn’t alone brought immense relief, and he began to find joy beyond professional achievements. We can all contribute to this social transformation by sharing our stories and creating safe spaces for those in midlife. Together, we place markers on the shore, guiding each other through this shared journey.

Can Marc Freedman's Vision of 'Encore Adulthood' Revolutionize Midlife Transitions?

Navigating midlife can often feel like an unexpected journey, where individuals find themselves grappling with dissatisfaction despite outward success. This stage of life often prompts a reevaluation of values and priorities, as seen through the experiences of Karl and others. There's a tendency for a happiness curve, where satisfaction dips in middle age but rises in later years. This pattern isn't merely cultural; it might be biologically ingrained, as seen in both human and primate studies.

The concept of happiness is complex and multifaceted, not solely tied to material gains but deeply influenced by social and relational factors. Research indicates that as people age, they often shift their focus from ambition to connection, finding fulfillment in relationships and community rather than individual achievements. This transformation suggests that wisdom and emotional richness are hallmarks of aging.

Midlife challenges can be reframed as normal developmental stages rather than crises, with acceptance and patience as key strategies for navigating this transition. Social support and shared narratives can provide essential grounding during this period. 

As society evolves, there's a growing recognition of the need for structures and support systems that accommodate the unique challenges of midlife, fostering a sense of purpose and connection. This collective shift towards understanding and embracing the potential of later life stages can lead to a more fulfilling and harmonious journey.

Home

Trending Books

News & Mags

Relax

Curated

Collections

Key Ideas & Notes

Insights

Highlights & Bookmarks

Listening History

Key Ideas

#1