Ever questioned the popular advice to follow your passion? What if this well-intentioned counsel was leading you astray? Ready to break free from the passion trap and cultivate a fulfilling, mission-driven career? Dive into this riveting exploration of the passion hypothesis and discover a more nuanced path to career satisfaction. With compelling cases from Steve Jobs to Pardis Sabeti, learn how deliberate practice, career capital, and a craftsman mindset can transform your career. 

So Good They Can't Ignore You: Why Skills Trump Passion in the Quest for Work You Love

"Follow your passion" is dangerous advice. This revelation hit Thomas, a lay monk, while walking through the oak forests of the Zen Mountain Monastery in the Catskills. Despite nurturing a dream-job fantasy of living as a monk, Thomas found himself crying in the woods, questioning the very advice that had led him there.

Thomas's journey began with a deep interest in philosophy and theology, eventually leading to a master's degree in comparative religion. Convinced that Zen Buddhist practice held the key to a meaningful life, he traveled across East Asia, teaching English in South Korea and exploring China and Tibet. Yet, his romantic notions soon wore off, and he found himself in mundane jobs, still chasing the idea that Buddhism would bring happiness.

In London, Thomas discovered the Zen Mountain Monastery, known for its intense Zen practice. After nine months of rigorous application, he finally arrived. The monastery, set in a picturesque part of the Catskills, promised the fulfillment of his dreams. His days began at 4:30 A.M. with meditation, followed by chores and Dharma lectures. Yet, the reality was far from his fantasy.

Thomas's struggles intensified with the koans—Zen word puzzles meant to defy logical answers. The Mu koan, a significant milestone, haunted him for months until one day, while walking in the forest, he had an epiphany: "I" disappeared, and he understood the koan's essence. He had passed the first gate and became a serious Zen student.

However, this achievement brought a stark realization. Walking the same trail where he had cracked the koan, Thomas understood that the lectures and practices all revolved around this one insight. He had reached the zenith of his passion but felt no different—still plagued by the same worries and anxieties. Crying in the forest, he realized that merely following his passion had not brought the happiness he sought.

This belief that passion alone leads to happiness is frighteningly naïve. Thomas's journey illustrates that the path to a meaningful life is more complex than simply answering, "What should I do with my life?" His story resonates with the observations of a postdoctoral associate at MIT, who, in 2010, embarked on a quest to understand why some people love their work while others don't.

The conventional wisdom of "follow your passion" is flawed. It's not how most people find fulfilling careers, and for many, it leads to chronic job shifting and unrelenting angst. The key to a compelling career lies in developing rare and valuable skills—career capital—and then investing this capital into traits like autonomy and mastery that make a job great.

Instead of following your passion, let passion follow you in your quest to become exceptionally good at something. This shift from passion to ability and mastery is a radical yet essential change in perspective. By focusing on building skills and investing them wisely, you can create a meaningful and engaging working life.

Thomas eventually moved away from finding the right work to working right, building a genuine love for what he does. This is the happiness you should demand—rooted not in simplistic catchphrases but in a realistic path toward a fulfilling career.

Is Follow Your Passion Truly the Path to Happiness and Career Success?

In June 2005, Steve Jobs delivered a memorable commencement speech at Stanford, urging graduates to "find what you love" and not to settle until they did. This advice, encapsulating the Passion Hypothesis, quickly went viral, amassing millions of views and becoming a cornerstone of modern career advice.

The Passion Hypothesis suggests that the key to career fulfillment is to match your job to a pre-existing passion. This idea is pervasive, found in countless career-advice books and promoted by myriad self-help gurus. Titles like Career Match and Do What You Are promise that you’re just a few personality tests away from your dream job. However, a deeper look into how successful people like Steve Jobs really got started reveals a different story.

If you had met a young Steve Jobs before Apple, you'd find a man more interested in spiritual enlightenment than in technology or business. Jobs attended Reed College, dabbled in Western history, dance, and Eastern mysticism, and even took a spiritual journey to India. He stumbled into the tech world almost by accident, driven more by the promise of quick cash than by a deep-seated passion for electronics.

Jobs's story, far from being a straightforward tale of following one's passion, was filled with serendipity and small-time schemes that eventually led to Apple. This reality raises questions about the Passion Hypothesis. Should we mimic Jobs's eclectic path, trying various ventures until something sticks? Jobs himself seemed to find passion along the way, not at the outset.

This pattern of finding fulfilling work through a less direct path is common. The Roadtrip Nation project, where young people interviewed those with meaningful careers, found similar stories. Public radio host Ira Glass, for instance, emphasized that career fulfillment happens in stages and requires hard work and skill acquisition. 

Supporting this, research by Yale's Amy Wrzesniewski found that job satisfaction often grows with experience and mastery, not necessarily from initially following a passion. Her study of administrative assistants showed that those who saw their work as a calling had simply been in their jobs longer, gaining competence and autonomy over time.

Further, the Self-Determination Theory (SDT) reveals that intrinsic motivation in work stems from fulfilling three psychological needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. Passion, as it turns out, is more a side effect of developing these qualities than a starting point.

In essence, while "follow your passion" is a popular mantra, real-world examples and scientific research suggest a more nuanced approach: focus on building skills, gaining experience, and finding autonomy in your work. Passion, it seems, is something you cultivate, not something you start with.

Debunking the Passion Hypothesis: The Real Secret to Steve Jobs' Success and Occupational Happiness

The passion hypothesis gained traction with Richard Bolles’s 1970 book *What Color Is Your Parachute?*, which suggested that people should identify what they love to do and find a job that matches it. This notion was revolutionary at the time and has since influenced generations, becoming increasingly popular, especially among young people, who now expect work to be fulfilling and adventurous.

Despite the popularity of this idea, evidence suggests that it can lead to chronic job-hopping and self-doubt. A 2010 survey found that only 45% of Americans were satisfied with their jobs, down from 61% in 1987. Among young people, job dissatisfaction was even higher at 64%.

Books like Quarterlife Crisis highlight stories of young people who, despite following their passions, feel lost and unfulfilled. Scott, a passionate political worker, questions if his “perfect” job is fulfilling enough and continues searching for the ideal career. Jill and Elaine share similar feelings of confusion and dissatisfaction.

While some, like Rolling Stone critic Peter Travers or professional athletes, succeed by following their passions, these cases are rare and not universally applicable. Most people who love their work follow a more complex path than simply identifying a passion and pursuing it.

Instead of the passion hypothesis, we should adopt a "craftsman mindset," focusing on what value you can produce in your job rather than what the job offers you. This concept is illustrated through the story of Jordan Tice, a dedicated bluegrass musician who focuses intensely on honing his craft, spending hours perfecting new techniques. This mindset echoes comedian Steve Martin’s advice: “Be so good they can’t ignore you.”

The passion mindset, which focuses on finding the perfect job, often leads to dissatisfaction and confusion. In contrast, the craftsman mindset emphasizes skill and value, providing clarity and a path to career fulfillment.

Adopting the craftsman mindset is crucial for building a compelling career. By focusing on becoming exceptionally skilled at what you do, you can find satisfaction and passion in your work, irrespective of your initial feelings toward the job.

Is Following Your Passion Really the Key to Career Happiness?

If you want a great job, you need "career capital"—rare and valuable skills that you can trade for work that's creative, impactful, and gives you control. This isn't about chasing passion; it's about adopting a "craftsman mindset" focused on what you can offer the world. 

Steve Jobs walked into a computer store holding the rare and valuable circuit board of the Apple I. That early success gave him control, but to get even more, he had to up his game. Taking on investment and focusing on making an unbeatable product led to the Apple II, which skyrocketed his career.

Ira Glass, creator of This American Life, started from the bottom as a tape cutter at NPR. By honing his editing skills to perfection, he got opportunities to host segments, eventually landing his own show. His journey wasn't about innate talent but relentless improvement until his skills were too valuable to ignore.

Similarly, Al Merrick, a master surfboard shaper, started with boat-building skills and a love for surfing. It took hard work to make his boards competition-worthy. Once surf pros like Kelly Slater started winning on his boards, Merrick gained the freedom to work on his terms—an office by the beach and surf breaks whenever he wanted.

These stories illustrate the "Career Capital Theory of Great Work": to get traits like creativity, impact, and control, you need to offer something equally rare and valuable in return. But beware the pitfalls of the passion mindset, as shown by the contrasting fates of Lisa Feuer and Joe Duffy.

Feuer left a marketing career for a yoga business after a brief training course, believing passion alone would lead to success. Instead, she ended up on food stamps. Meanwhile, Duffy used his career capital to gradually gain more autonomy in advertising, ultimately running his own successful firm and enjoying a comfortable life.

The passion mindset can mislead people into undervaluing the importance of building skills. John, a recent college grad, exemplified a common dilemma. Unhappy in his tax consulting job, he wondered if he should stick with it. He was advised to leave because his job offered few opportunities for skill growth and had little positive impact—two disqualifiers for applying the craftsman mindset.

Finally, meet Alex Berger and Mike Jackson, two individuals who thrived by focusing on skill-building. Berger broke into the competitive world of TV writing not by following passion but by honing his craft relentlessly. He wrote scripts, sought feedback, and eventually sold a pilot to USA Network. Jackson, a cleantech venture capitalist, never planned his career meticulously. Instead, he gathered skills in energy markets and leveraged every opportunity, leading to a coveted job in Silicon Valley.

Both stories underscore a vital lesson: focus on getting good. The craftsman mindset, with its relentless dedication to improving what you can offer, is the key to building a career you love.

Career Capital: The Key to a Rewarding Career - Lessons from Steve Jobs, Ira Glass and Al Merrick

When Cal Newport, the author, was twelve, he picked up a guitar and formed a band named Rocking Chair. They performed at talent shows and even played in a graveyard once, but despite his dedication, he was just an average player by the time he graduated high school. Meanwhile, Jordan Tice, who also started playing at twelve, was touring professionally and had a record deal by the same age. So, what set them apart?

The answer lies in "deliberate practice". Unlike Newport's repetitive, comfort-zone playing, Jordan constantly pushed his limits, learning complicated leads by ear and receiving immediate feedback from his teacher. His practice was intense and uncomfortable, a stark contrast to Newport's reluctance to venture beyond familiar songs.

This concept isn’t limited to music. Mark Casstevens, an award-winning studio musician, also highlighted the need for relentless skill-stretching practice. It’s a universal principle that applies to fields as diverse as chess, medicine, and writing.

Take chess, for example. Studies by psychologists like Neil Charness reveal that grand masters dedicate significantly more hours to serious study—deliberate practice—than to just playing games. This kind of study involves challenging tasks and immediate feedback, essential for skill improvement.

In his own journey, Newport realized that most knowledge workers hit a performance plateau because they don’t engage in deliberate practice. This insight was transformative. If you can integrate deliberate practice into your work, you can surpass your peers and acquire valuable career capital.

Consider Alex Berger and Mike Jackson, two professionals who excelled by adopting deliberate practice. Alex, now a television writer, relentlessly sought feedback and took on multiple projects beyond his comfort zone. Mike, a venture capitalist, meticulously tracked his work to focus on what truly mattered, ignoring trivial distractions like excessive email.

Another key to loving your work is control. Newport visited Ryan Voiland’s farm, Red Fire Farm, to understand why his lifestyle was so appealing. Ryan and his wife, Sarah, have autonomy over their work, a trait that makes their challenging but fulfilling lives attractive. Control isn’t just beneficial for farmers; it’s universally linked to better performance and happiness across various fields.

In essence, to create work you love, you need to acquire career capital through deliberate practice and then invest this capital into gaining control over your work. This approach, as demonstrated by Jordan Tice, grand master chess players, and professionals like Alex and Mike, can help you become so good they can't ignore you.

Can Deliberate Practice and Control in Work Life Make You So Good They Can't Ignore You?

Meet Jane. She was an ambitious student with top scores and a competitive university background. Yet, she craved an adventurous life rather than a traditional career path. Her bold plan included cycling across continents, surviving in the wilderness, and learning fire-breathing, all financed by low-maintenance websites generating $3,000 monthly. 

Unfortunately, Jane dropped out of college, pursued various ventures, but failed to gain financial independence. Her blog, intended to be her revenue foundation, stalled with only three posts in nine months. She discovered a harsh truth: gaining control without career capital is unsustainable.

Jane’s story highlights the First Control Trap: pursuing control without career capital leads to failure. Unlike Jane, Ryan of Red Fire Farm spent a decade building relevant skills before pursuing farming full-time. This career capital allowed him to succeed. Similarly, Lisa Feuer’s yoga business flopped due to her lack of expertise, resulting in her ending up on food stamps. Many lifestyle designers, inspired by Timothy Ferriss, overlook the necessity of career capital, leading to unsustainable ventures.

Lulu Young, a software developer, navigated the First Control Trap successfully. Starting at the bottom in Quality Assurance, she used her UNIX skills to automate testing, gaining valuable career capital. She leveraged this to negotiate a 30-hour workweek and pursue a philosophy degree. Later, she joined a start-up, eventually becoming a freelance developer, enjoying extreme flexibility and control over her work life. Her journey exemplifies acquiring control backed by career capital, avoiding the pitfalls Jane faced.

Lulu’s story also introduces the Second Control Trap: acquiring control can generate resistance from employers who value your contributions. Employers may resist granting more autonomy as it reduces productivity. Lulu faced this when negotiating her work schedule and transitioning to freelance work. Similarly, Lewis, a medical resident, faced resistance when taking a break to start a company. Both stories highlight the need for courage and timing in pursuing control, balancing career capital with resistance.

Courage is crucial but must be deployed wisely. The challenge is discerning when to pursue control. The First Control Trap cautions against premature bids for autonomy, while the Second Control Trap warns of resistance once career capital is established. Understanding these traps is key to creating a fulfilling career, requiring a nuanced approach beyond simplistic courage slogans.

Career Capital: The Key to Control and Autonomy in Your Career

Derek Sivers, a self-proclaimed control freak, shared an insightful TED talk in 2010 about leadership. He showcased a video where a lone dancer eventually inspired a crowd to join him. Through his career, Derek has often been that initial dancer, taking risky yet calculated moves designed to maximize control over his life and work.

Derek’s journey began in 1992 when he left a secure job at Warner Bros. to pursue music. He later founded CD Baby in 1997, a platform supporting independent musicians before the iTunes era. His venture grew significantly, leading him to sell it for $22 million in 2008. Instead of following conventional wisdom, Derek donated the proceeds to charity and began traveling, seeking new experiences and challenges.

What sets Derek apart is his principle of financial viability: "Do what people are willing to pay for." This rule isn’t about accumulating wealth but using money as an indicator of value. For instance, Derek didn’t quit his day job until his music earnings surpassed his salary. Similarly, he scaled CD Baby by reinvesting its earnings.

This principle, termed the Law of Financial Viability, advises pursuing control only if there’s evidence people will pay for it. This approach minimizes risk and ensures that your efforts are valued. It applies broadly, from securing loans to negotiating flexible work arrangements.

Examples like Ryan Voiland, who secured a loan to start his farm, and Lulu, who negotiated reduced work hours, illustrate this principle. Conversely, people who ignore this law, like Jane who dropped out of college without a viable plan, often struggle. Law of Financial Viability is a crucial tool for navigating the control traps in your career, ensuring that your efforts are both valuable and sustainable.

Next, Pardis Sabeti, a Harvard professor of evolutionary biology, exemplifies the power of having a unifying mission in your career. Pardis’s mission is to eradicate ancient diseases using computational genetics. Her work is not just about academic accolades but driven by a deeper purpose, providing her with energy and enthusiasm.

Pardis’s algorithm searches for genes that have evolved to resist diseases like Lhassa fever, malaria, and the bubonic plague. Her mission has garnered significant funding and recognition, emphasizing the importance of having a compelling focus.

A mission provides a sense of purpose and maximizes your impact, leading to greater satisfaction and resilience. Pardis's joy in her work extends to her hobbies, like playing in a band and leading a lab volleyball team, showcasing a balanced and fulfilling life.

To integrate a mission into your career, you must first build career capital through mastery of rare and valuable skills. This foundation allows you to pursue meaningful and impactful goals. Additionally, systematically experimenting with different proto-missions and adopting a marketing mindset are essential steps in making a mission a reality.

In essence, a mission-driven career provides direction and fulfillment, making work a source of joy and purpose.

Can the Law of Financial Viability and a Mission-Driven Career Lead to Unparalleled Success?

Sarah, a former newspaper editor, transitioned to studying cognitive science in graduate school. Despite her newfound confidence, she soon became overwhelmed by the lack of a focused mission and felt overshadowed by her peers. Jane, who dropped out of college to start a nonprofit aimed at "health, human potential, and a life well-lived," also floundered due to vague goals and a lack of financial support.

Both Sarah and Jane's stories highlight the difficulty of sustaining a mission without relevant career capital. Their experiences contrast sharply with Pardis Sabeti, whose successful research career stemmed from a clear mission developed over time.

While attending a computer science conference, the author noticed several researchers independently tackling the same problem using a specific technique. This phenomenon, known as "multiples," is common in scientific history. Steven Johnson, in his book "Where Good Ideas Come From," attributes this to the "adjacent possible," where new ideas emerge from the current cutting edge of a field.

To identify a compelling career mission, one must first reach the cutting edge of their field, where the adjacent possible becomes visible. Sarah's struggles stemmed from her attempt to find a mission too early in her graduate studies. Jane, too, lacked the necessary capital to support her nonprofit vision. The process of getting to the cutting edge involves years of work and the accumulation of rare and valuable skills, known as "career capital."

Pardis Sabeti's journey illustrates the importance of patience in building career capital. Initially interested in math, biology, and medicine, she eventually focused on computational genetics to combat ancient diseases. Her success came after years of honing her skills and gaining recognition in her field.

Despite having career capital, the author struggled to find a mission-driven career. Kirk French, an archaeologist, provides an example of how to make this leap. Hosting the TV show "American Treasures" allowed him to popularize archaeology in an exciting way.

Kirk's path to success was incremental. He started with small projects, like digitizing old film reels and filming exploratory footage. These "little bets" provided valuable feedback and led to his breakthrough with "The Armchair Archaeologist." Similarly, Pardis Sabeti's journey involved a series of small experiments that eventually led to her successful research career.

To succeed in a mission, one needs both career capital and a strategy of little bets. These small, concrete experiments help explore the specific avenues surrounding a general mission, maximizing the chances of success.

By focusing on accumulating career capital and making incremental progress through little bets, individuals can identify and successfully pursue compelling career missions.

Unlocking Success: A Journey of Career Capital and Little Bets

Giles Bowkett didn't always love his career. He was once broke, unemployed, and bored at jobs that didn't inspire him. His breakthrough came in 2008 when he became a star in the Ruby programming community. Giles's rise to fame began with his mission to merge art and Ruby programming, culminating in his creation of Archaeopteryx, an AI program that composes dance music. This innovative project made him a celebrity among Ruby programmers worldwide.

Giles leveraged his newfound fame to work at top firms, double his salary, and later pursue entrepreneurial ventures. His blog and web applications became popular, and he even dabbled in filmmaking with hitRECord, a company started by actor Joseph Gordon-Levitt. Giles’s dynamic career, bouncing from opportunity to opportunity, suited his hyperkinetic personality perfectly.

Giles's journey began when he left Santa Fe College and explored various creative pursuits, from screenwriting to music. He eventually discovered HTML, Java, and Perl, which positioned him well during the dot-com boom. However, the first dot-com crash led him to a revelation: he needed a mission to avoid career stagnation. He decided to combine his artistic and technical skills and sought guidance through two influential books: Seth Godin's "Purple Cow" and Chad Fowler's "My Job Went to India."

Godin's concept of creating "purple cows"—remarkable projects that compel people to talk about them—resonated with Giles. Fowler's advice to contribute to open-source software provided the ideal platform. Giles merged these ideas and created Archaeopteryx, a Ruby program that generated real music, making it a "purple cow" in the open-source community.

Reflecting on Giles's story, it becomes clear that a successful mission-driven project must be remarkable in two ways: it must compel people to talk about it, and it must be launched in a venue conducive to such discussions. Giles’s Archaeopteryx did just that, captivating the Ruby community and spreading through open-source channels.

This principle applies beyond programming. For example, Pardis Sabeti's mission to use genetics to fight infectious diseases led her to a remarkable project of tracking human evolution, published in peer-reviewed journals. Similarly, Kirk French popularized archaeology through a TV show, reaching a wide audience.

How Did Giles Bowkett's Unconventional Approach Revolutionize Ruby Programming?

The popular advice of "follow your passion" is often misguided. It can lead to disappointment and chronic job-hopping because it relies on the assumption that pre-existing passions will naturally align with fulfilling careers. Instead, the path to career satisfaction is more about developing rare and valuable skills—what can be termed as "career capital." By focusing on ability and mastery, one builds a foundation that can be leveraged to gain autonomy and control in one's work.

Cultivating a fulfilling career involves a shift from a "passion mindset" to a "craftsman mindset," where the emphasis is on what value you can produce rather than what the job can offer you. This approach encourages deliberate practice—constantly challenging oneself and seeking feedback to improve skills. With this career capital, one can then pursue traits like creativity, impact, and control, which are essential for a meaningful job.

Additionally, having a compelling mission can provide direction and fulfillment in one's career. However, achieving this requires first reaching the cutting edge of your field and systematically experimenting with small, manageable projects or "little bets" to explore potential avenues for impact. This incremental approach, combined with a marketer's mindset to ensure your projects are remarkable and well-publicized, can transform an idea into a successful mission-driven career.

Ultimately, it's about being strategic and patient—acquiring skills, gaining experience, and then using this foundation to create and pursue meaningful work. This nuanced approach contrasts sharply with the simplistic advice of "follow your passion" and offers a more realistic path to career happiness.

Home

Trending Books

News & Mags

Relax

Curated

Collections

Key Ideas & Notes

Insights

Highlights & Bookmarks

Listening History

So Good They Can't Ignore You: Why Skills Trump Passion in the Quest for Work You Love

Cal Newport

Ever questioned the popular advice to follow your passion?

What if this well-intentioned counsel was leading you astray?

Ready to break free from the passion trap and cultivate a fulfilling, mission-driven career?

Dive into this riveting exploration of the passion hypothesis and discover a more nuanced path to career satisfaction. With compelling cases from Steve Jobs to Pardis Sabeti, learn how deliberate practice, career capital, and a craftsman mindset can transform your career.

Key Ideas

#1