How can the concept of sustained attention transform your perception of reality? How did the teachings of the ancient philosopher Epicurus or the commune movement of the 1960s resonate with today's need for balance and perspective? How can we actively resist the attention economy and find value in 'useless' activities? Dive into this compelling exploration of attention, resistance, and interconnectedness in our hyper-connected world.

How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy

In a world obsessed with productivity, nothing is harder to do than nothing. We're constantly driven to optimize every moment, turning our free time into financial resources. Our lives are streamlined, branded, and evaluated by algorithms, leaving us overstimulated and unable to sustain deep thought. 

This relentless busyness isn't new. Robert Louis Stevenson once called it a “symptom of deficient vitality," and Seneca warned about wasting life on trivial pursuits. Today, the stakes are even higher. Our complex times demand nuanced conversations, yet limitless connectivity reduces in-person interaction to mere transactions, eroding the richness of communication.

The arts, too, suffer in a system that values only the bottom line. There's an impatience with anything nuanced or poetic because it offers no immediate deliverables. This is why the current culture often dismisses the importance of art and observation.

But resistance is possible. It involves reclaiming time and space from the attention economy, not by abandoning technology but by rejecting its capitalist uses. Doing nothing becomes an act of political resistance, a refusal to validate a world where value is measured solely by productivity. This isn’t about a weekend retreat to recharge for more work. It’s about questioning the very definition of productivity.

True resistance means embracing the local and the present, fostering a bioregional awareness that recognizes our interconnectedness with the natural world. It's about seeing productivity not as relentless output but as the maintenance of life and relationships.

Ultimately, the goal is to replant our focus in the physical realm, away from the digital distractions that fragment our attention. This shift allows us to cultivate a deeper awareness of our surroundings and the communities—human and more-than-human—that inhabit them. It’s a call to recognize and celebrate the richness of life that doesn't fit into a capitalist framework, to find fulfillment in being rather than doing.

By reclaiming our attention, we can foster meaningful connections and restore the ecosystems—both cultural and biological—that sustain us. Doing nothing, in this sense, is a radical act of defiance and a step towards a more attentive, connected, and alive existence.

Is Doing Nothing the Ultimate Act of Defiance in Our Productivity-Obsessed World?

In early 2017, Jenny Odell was invited to give a keynote at EYEO, an art and technology conference. She titled her talk "How to Do Nothing" without knowing what it would entail. She found inspiration in the Morcom Amphitheatre of Roses in Oakland, a sanctuary where she often escaped from her computer and the pressures of productivity.

The Rose Garden became a place for her to practice the art of doing nothing, sitting quietly and letting herself absorb the surroundings. This act of doing nothing was not just an escape but a necessary pause to foster meaningful thoughts and creativity. Doing nothing, she realized, was a precursor to having something valuable to say. 

In today's gig economy, where every moment is monetized, such pauses are rare and undervalued. The constant drive to be productive, to turn every hour into a unit of economic value, leaves little room for the kind of deep, contemplative thinking that leads to true creativity. This relentless productivity was captured perfectly by a Fiverr ad that celebrated sleep deprivation and the sacrifice of personal well-being for constant output. 

However, stepping back and embracing moments of nothingness can counteract this. It allows for a deeper connection with the world, both human and natural. The practice of doing nothing—whether it’s bird-watching, sitting in a garden, or simply listening—provides a break from the digital overload and incessant chatter that surrounds us.

Public spaces like the Rose Garden offer a haven from the commercialization of every aspect of life. These spaces, built for the community and maintained with care, remind us of the importance of non-commercial activities and the need to protect such sanctuaries. 

In a society that values growth and novelty over maintenance and care, doing nothing becomes a radical act. It’s about reclaiming time for self-preservation, reflection, and genuine creativity. It’s about recognizing that not every moment needs to be productive in the capitalist sense, but rather, it can be meaningful in a human sense.

Embracing 'Doing Nothing': A Radical Act of Creativity in the Age of Relentless Productivity

Levi Felix, an early digital detox advocate, had a transformative moment after burning out from a 70-hour workweek. He and his partner, Brooke Dean, founded Camp Grounded, a digital detox camp for adults, inspired by their unplugged travels in Cambodia.

At Camp Grounded, visitors surrendered their phones and engaged in analog activities like archery and creative writing on typewriters. Felix’s meticulous planning, likely influenced by his love for Burning Man, made the camp a blend of nature and whimsical fun. It was a temporary escape from the digital whirlwind, a retreat meticulously designed to offer peace and reflection.

Yet, despite its anti-tech stance, Digital Detox, the camp’s parent company, began offering corporate retreats for tech giants like Yelp and Airbnb, subtly reinforcing the productivity-driven world Felix initially sought to escape.

As idyllic as these retreats may seem, they offer only a fleeting respite. The world, with all its demands and responsibilities, waits just outside the camp gates. Felix, who had once found solace in a similar retreat, understood this. His journey through burnout and recovery revealed that simply unplugging wasn't enough. True change required a fundamental reevaluation of one's relationship with technology and society.

Retreats like Camp Grounded can provide valuable insights and moments of clarity, but they are not the ultimate solution. They are temporary sanctuaries that allow us to pause and reflect but not to escape indefinitely. The challenge lies in integrating the lessons learned in these brief respites into our daily lives, creating sustainable habits that balance our digital and analog worlds.

Felix's vision was not just about taking a break but about fostering a long-term, healthier relationship with technology. This requires more than periodic retreats; it demands a cultural shift. We need to cultivate environments that prioritize human connection and mindfulness in the midst of our daily routines. The goal is to live in a way that allows us to stay grounded and connected, even amid the chaos.

Can Temporary Digital Detox Retreats Truly Cure Our Technology Burnout?

In 2008, the employees at Deloitte were puzzled by a new recruit who spent her days staring into space and riding elevators. This wasn't typical trainee behavior; it was actually a performance piece by Finnish artist Pilvi Takala, known for her unconventional art that challenges social norms. 

Her silent, inactive presence unsettled her coworkers, leading to frantic emails and a collective sense of unease. Takala’s work, like her piece "Bag Lady," where she wandered a mall with a clear bag full of euros, forces people to confront their own assumptions and societal norms.

Takala's approach echoes the ancient philosopher Diogenes of Sinope, who lived his life in public defiance of societal conventions. Diogenes, famous for living in a tub and searching for an honest man with a lantern, used his actions to challenge the norms of his time, much like Takala. His notorious encounter with Alexander the Great, where he asked the emperor to "stand out of my light," is a testament to his radical individualism and refusal to conform.

Diogenes' acts can be seen as early forms of performance art, aiming to wake people from their complacency. His methods of living simply, walking backward, and rolling in hot sand or hugging snowy statues were all ways to shock people into questioning their routines and values.

Centuries later, Thoreau's act of refusal in "Civil Disobedience," where he rejected paying taxes to protest slavery and the Mexican-American War, mirrors this spirit of nonconformity. Thoreau's retreat to Walden Pond was about stripping life down to its essentials to confront the fundamental truths, much like Takala’s and Diogenes’s disruptions sought to reveal deeper societal truths.

In modern times, the 1934 San Francisco longshoremen’s strike showed collective refusal's power. The dockworkers, tired of exploitation, organized a massive strike that disrupted the West Coast ports. Their disciplined, collective action, supported by networks of solidarity, culminated in a silent, powerful march after police violence claimed two lives, leading to a city-wide general strike.

These acts of refusal—whether individual like Diogenes and Thoreau or collective like the longshoremen—demonstrate the transformative power of saying no, challenging norms, and standing apart from the flow of everyday life. They remind us that meaningful change often starts with the courage to refuse and the discipline to persist.

From Diogenes to Deloitte: The Art of Radical Refusal

In Zen, there's a saying: "If something is boring after two minutes, try it for four. If still boring, then eight. Then sixteen. Then thirty-two. Eventually, one discovers that it is not boring at all." This adage speaks to the transformative power of sustained attention, a skill that can turn the mundane into the extraordinary.

Take, for instance, the seemingly featureless sprawl of Cupertino, California. For a teenager growing up there in the early 2000s, it was a place defined by shopping centers and office parks, devoid of a compelling identity. 

Yet, beneath this veneer of sameness was a rich tapestry of hidden stories and unnoticed details, waiting to be discovered by those who took the time to look closely. The shopping centers, for example, were built on historical sites—Cupertino's first post office, general store, and blacksmith shop—but these connections were lost amid the modern landscape of consumer culture.

This kind of deep perception is not limited to places but extends to art and experiences as well. Consider the work of David Hockney, an artist who explored the relationship between time and seeing. Hockney’s experiments with photography aimed to capture the fluid, fragmented nature of human vision. 

By piecing together Polaroids into grids, he created a dynamic, almost cubist representation of reality, inviting viewers to see through multiple perspectives simultaneously. His work reveals that sustained attention can transform a static image into a living experience, much like how focusing on a seemingly boring task can reveal its hidden richness.

This idea of deep attention transforming our perception was echoed during a performance of John Cage's "Song Books" at the Davies Symphony Hall. Cage's work, which often involves silence and ambient noise, redefines what music could be. After attending a performance, the mundane sounds of city life—cars, footsteps, the wind—suddenly become vibrant and full of detail. This shift in perception is not just an artistic revelation but a profound change in how one could experience the world.

Similarly, the film "The Exchange" illustrates how even the smallest shifts in perception can make the familiar seem strange and new. The protagonist, disoriented by a chance encounter, begins to see his everyday surroundings with fresh eyes, uncovering the extraordinary in the ordinary.

This attentional shift is not just about seeing new things but also about transcending the self. Philosopher Martin Buber’s concept of I-Thou relationships emphasizes meeting the world with full attention, where the other (a person, a tree, or an artwork) is encountered in its full, irreducible reality. This kind of attention fosters a deeper connection and understanding, moving beyond superficial interactions.

In practical terms, enhancing our attention can have remarkable impacts, from improving athletic performance through visual training apps to recognizing and overcoming implicit biases in social interactions. Sustained attention can change how we perceive and interact with the world, making us more aware and responsive to our surroundings.

Ultimately, deepening our attention is a powerful tool for enriching our lives. It allows us to see the hidden depths in everyday experiences, transforming boredom into a gateway to deeper understanding and connection. Whether through art, nature, or daily activities, the practice of sustained attention can reveal the profound beauty and complexity of the world around us.

Can Sustained Attention Transform Boredom into a Gateway for Deeper Understanding?

On a typical Saturday in 2017, an ordinary walk to the grocery store transformed into a profound lesson in human connection for Jenny Odell. Cresting a hill, she encountered a young woman having a seizure. In a blur of action, she dialed 911 and called for help, feeling an immense responsibility for the stranger lying on the ground. 

The woman’s confused and suspicious gaze, as she regained consciousness, was a poignant reminder of the fragility and unpredictability of life. Holding her distressed dog’s leash, Odell felt a profound, fleeting connection to this stranger. Once the paramedics arrived, she resumed her grocery run, but everything felt different. The mundane world of cereal aisles and apple bins was charged with the miracle that they all were simply alive.

This incident mirrors a broader truth about urban life and our shared spaces. Public transportation, crowded streets, and city parks force us into proximity with strangers, creating opportunities for unexpected encounters. These moments can transform our perception of others from mere obstacles into fellow travelers, each with their own rich tapestry of experiences, dreams, and struggles.

True community emerges when we recognize and embrace these encounters. It's about more than just living near others; it involves engaging with and caring for the people who share our physical and social spaces. During disasters, it's often neighbors, not distant connections, who come together to provide immediate support. Such solidarity not only meets practical needs but also offers emotional sustenance, fostering a sense of belonging and purpose.

The richness of life, then, is found in these connections. By expanding our attention beyond our immediate circles and considering the lives of those around us, we cultivate a more inclusive and compassionate worldview. This interconnectedness extends to our relationship with the natural world, where recognizing the agency and vitality of non-human life forms deepens our sense of kinship and responsibility.

Embracing Human Connections: The Interwoven Tapestry of Urban Life

Imagine scrolling through your social media feed: a tragic news story, a joke, a political rant, a friend's baby photos, a meme, and an advertisement—all in the space of a few seconds. The flood of disparate information leaves you feeling confused and overwhelmed. 

This disorienting experience is known as "context collapse," where the boundaries between different types of content blur, and their original context gets lost. Context collapse is problematic because it strips away the spatial and temporal context that gives meaning to information. 

On platforms like Twitter and Facebook, diverse audiences—friends, family, employers, and even strangers—converge in a single space. This forces users to present a sanitized version of themselves, limiting authentic expression and meaningful dialogue. The rapid-fire nature of social media also leads to a temporal collapse, where past, present, and future meld into a continuous, chaotic present, making it hard to think deeply or act thoughtfully.

This lack of context is often exploited maliciously. For instance, far-right propagandists dig up old tweets to paint people in the worst possible light, and the outrage spreads like wildfire. The resulting tweet storms generate more confusion and anger than understanding, benefiting the platform's engagement metrics but leaving users feeling disconnected and anxious.

Without context, social media interactions become shallow and reactionary. Important issues get lost in the noise, and our ability to engage thoughtfully diminishes. We need platforms that respect our need for context, allowing us to think and communicate more deeply and authentically. This could mean slower, more intentional networks that prioritize meaningful connections over constant engagement.

Ultimately, resisting the attention economy means reclaiming our attention and engaging deeply with our surroundings and communities. This approach nurtures a richer, more diverse self, connected to the world and others in meaningful ways.

Is Social Media's Context Collapse Undermining Our Mental Landscapes?

Our current society, propelled by capitalism, is deeply obsessed with productivity, reducing much of our lives to mere financial transactions. This quest for constant productivity diminishes the value of art, deep thought, and meaningful conversation. 

However, we can resist this by refusing to validate a world where value is solely measured by output and instead, embracing mindful living that fosters deep connections and nurtures ecosystems, both culturally and biologically. 

True resistance involves fostering a bioregional awareness that recognizes our interconnectedness with the natural world and sees productivity as the maintenance of life and relationships. It's about finding fulfillment in being rather than doing. This shift allows us to cultivate a deeper awareness of our surroundings and the communities that inhabit them. 

Digital detox camps and retreats can provide valuable insights and moments of clarity, but they are not the ultimate solution. They are temporary sanctuaries that allow us to pause and reflect but not to escape indefinitely. True change requires a fundamental reevaluation of our relationship with technology and society, creating sustainable habits that balance our digital and analog worlds.

Historical acts of refusal, whether individual or collective, remind us of the power of saying no, challenging norms and standing apart from the flow of everyday life, and often lead to transformative change. This principle can be applied to our relationship with technology and productivity. 

Sustained attention, the practice of focusing entirely on one task or subject for a prolonged period, can transform the mundane into the extraordinary. It allows us to see the hidden depths in everyday experiences, transforming boredom into a gateway to deeper understanding and connection. 

Lastly, our sense of community comes from recognizing and embracing the lives of those around us, fostering a more inclusive and compassionate worldview. This interconnectedness extends to our relationship with the natural world, deepening our sense of kinship and responsibility. 

The concept of 'context collapse' seen on social media platforms, where diverse audiences converge in a single space, strips away the spatial and temporal context that gives meaning to information, leading to shallow and reactionary social media interactions. To counter this, we need to create slower, more intentional networks that prioritize meaningful connections over constant engagement.

Home

Trending Books

News & Mags

Relax

Curated

Collections

Key Ideas & Notes

Insights

Highlights & Bookmarks

Listening History

How can the concept of sustained attention transform your perception of reality?

How did the teachings of the ancient philosopher Epicurus or the commune movement of the 1960s resonate with today's need for balance and perspective?

How can we actively resist the attention economy and find value in 'useless' activities?

Dive into this compelling exploration of attention, resistance, and interconnectedness in our hyper-connected world.

Improve your Career, Health & Life with 15min insights from 9000+ non-fiction books

Key Ideas

#1