Ready to dive into the secretive world of high-frequency trading? Curious about how a few determined individuals dared to challenge the entrenched norms of Wall Street? Intrigued about how a Russian programmer's arrest unveiled the immense power of market-manipulating software? Join us as we unravel the journey of Brad Katsuyama, Ronan Ryan, and Sergey Aleynikov, and their fight for transparency and fairness amidst the chaotic landscape of modern financial trading.

Flash Boys: A Wall Street Revolt

Michael Lewis, the author, first heard about Sergey Aleynikov, a Russian programmer at Goldman Sachs, in 2009 when he was arrested for allegedly stealing high-frequency trading code. This intrigued Lewis because it highlighted how secretive and powerful market-manipulating software had become. It also raised questions about the enigmatic world of high-frequency trading (HFT).

Determined to understand more, Lewis found himself in a room at One Liberty Plaza, surrounded by ex-Wall Street insiders who had turned against the industry. These experts were tackling the very issues that Aleynikov had been working on.

Lewis' curiosity about financial markets dated back to 1987 when he witnessed a stock market crash from Salomon Brothers' trading floor. The crash showed how unpredictable Wall Street could be and set the stage for computers to take over trading, a shift that has only accelerated since.

Fast forward to 2009, and the U.S. stock market had moved into hidden, computer-driven operations. The market's opaque nature left the average investor clueless about the true mechanics behind their trades. This book aims to shed light on that hidden world.

One central figure in this narrative is a Canadian who discovered the magnitude of the stakes in the financial game. In 2009, a mysterious line was being laid by an army of workers who had no idea what they were building. This line was a one-and-a-half-inch-wide plastic tube housing fiber-optic strands, destined to connect a Chicago data center to a New Jersey stock exchange. The purpose? To create the fastest trading route, shaving milliseconds off trade times and giving an edge to those who could afford it.

Dan Spivey, a former stockbroker from Mississippi, was the mastermind behind this project. He realized that existing telecom routes were too slow and inconsistent for high-frequency trading. Spivey devised a plan to lay fiber along the straightest possible path, cutting through mountains and under rivers, to minimize the distance between Chicago and New York.

With funding from Jim Barksdale, the former Netscape CEO, Spivey and his team embarked on this ambitious $300 million project. They named it Spread Networks and kept it under wraps, using shell companies to maintain secrecy.

The construction involved tunneling through the Allegheny Mountains and navigating numerous obstacles. It was a monumental task that required innovative solutions, like renting a specialized drill from Brazil and boring through bridge pylons.

When Spread Networks finally revealed their line in 2010, Wall Street was astonished. The financial markets had changed so rapidly that even professionals struggled to keep up. The new line promised unprecedented speed, essential for high-frequency traders whose strategies depended on being faster than their competition.

The reaction from Wall Street firms ranged from awe to hostility. Some traders were willing to pay millions for access, while others were furious about the exclusivity and high costs. Despite the challenges, Spread Networks succeeded in selling their line, proving that in the world of high-frequency trading, every millisecond counts.

Did High-Frequency Trading Secretly Change Wall Street Forever?

Brad Katsuyama had always felt detached from Wall Street's chaos, working for the Royal Bank of Canada (RBC), a bank known for its stability and ethical stance. But a move from Toronto to New York thrust him into the heart of American excess and extravagance, a stark contrast to his Canadian upbringing. Brad quickly realized that debt-driven lifestyles and aggressive behaviors were the norm in the U.S.

Despite his initial culture shock, Brad thrived on Wall Street, becoming a successful trader and earning the nickname "the golden child" at RBC. But his troubles began in late 2006 when RBC acquired Carlin Financial, an electronic trading firm. The merger brought a clash of cultures, with Carlin's aggressive trading practices jarring against RBC's mild-mannered ethos.

Brad's real problems started with the technology from Carlin. His trading screens, once reliable, began to mislead him. Orders would disappear, causing unexpected market moves and losses. Frustrated, Brad and his team set out to investigate. They realized that orders were being front-run by high-frequency traders (HFTs), exploiting tiny time differences between exchanges to profit at others' expense.

Determined to solve the mystery, Brad enlisted Rob Park, a talented programmer, to help. Together, they discovered that by synchronizing the times at which orders reached different exchanges, they could prevent front-running. This tool, named Thor, became a game-changer, allowing traders to see the real market once again.

However, Brad's mission wasn't just about making a profit. He wanted to educate investors about the systemic issues in the stock market. Despite pressure from within RBC to stay silent, Brad believed in transparency and honesty. He argued that RBC should expose the predatory practices of HFTs and position itself as the only broker committed to fairness.

Brad's journey highlighted a critical flaw in the financial system: the market was no longer a level playing field. His work with Thor not only provided a solution but also raised awareness about the need for greater transparency and integrity in trading. Through persistence and a commitment to truth, Brad Katsuyama became a beacon of hope in a market riddled with deception.

Brad Katsuyama: The Maverick Trader Who Exposed Wall Street's Dark Side

Ronan Ryan didn’t fit the stereotypical image of a Wall Street trader. With his stooped shoulders and cautious demeanor, he felt more like an outsider than one of the feared and respected finance moguls. Born in Dublin and raised in a modest Irish family, Ronan moved to America at sixteen when his father was assigned to attract American companies to Ireland. 

Despite his father's lack of wealth, he managed to send Ronan to a public high school in Greenwich, Connecticut, a community that starkly contrasted with their Irish roots.

Ronan was fascinated by Wall Street but struggled to break into the industry. After graduating from Fairfield University, his attempts to land a job on Wall Street led him to a back-office role at Chemical Bank, which fell through. Eventually, he secured a job in the telecom industry with MCI Communications, thanks to an Irish connection. His first major task was to deliver new pagers to a Wall Street firm, an experience that involved dealing with disgruntled employees.

Despite his detour into telecom, Ronan’s ambition to work on Wall Street persisted. He learned the intricacies of the U.S. telecom system, gaining expertise in technology and fiber optics. This knowledge became invaluable as financial firms increasingly relied on rapid data transmission for trading. His skills led him to various telecom companies, and by 2005, he was deeply involved in optimizing data routes for Wall Street banks.

Ronan’s big break came when he was hired by BT Radianz to sell "proximity services," allowing financial firms to position their computers close to stock exchange servers for faster trading. He became a pioneer in reducing latency, the time it took for trading signals to travel, from milliseconds to microseconds. His expertise made him a sought-after consultant for high-frequency trading firms.

In 2009, Ronan was approached by Brad Katsuyama from the Royal Bank of Canada (RBC). Brad had been struggling to understand and combat the predatory high-frequency trading (HFT) practices that were disrupting the market. Ronan’s insights into the telecom and data transmission aspects of trading helped Brad piece together the puzzle. Together with Rob Park, they developed Thor, a system designed to protect investors from HFT exploitation by synchronizing the arrival times of trading orders across different exchanges.

Ronan’s unconventional background and technical knowledge made him an unlikely but effective advocate against the opaque and often predatory practices of high-frequency trading. His collaboration with Brad at RBC led to significant changes in the trading landscape, exposing the hidden mechanisms that disadvantaged ordinary investors and challenging the status quo on Wall Street. Their efforts culminated in educating major investors about the inner workings of the market, highlighting the need for transparency and fairness in financial trading.

How Did Ryan and Katsuyama Revolutionize Wall Street's Battle Against High-Frequency Trading?

By the end of 2010, Brad Katsuyama and his team had developed a tool to protect investors from a new breed of stock market predators: high-frequency traders (HFT). Brad, with limited knowledge of the HFT world, relied on insights from industry insiders like Ronan. 

The aftermath of the financial crisis opened doors for Brad to recruit disillusioned Wall Street employees. One such recruit was John Schwall, a former engineer turned product manager at Banc of America Securities. Schwall, who narrowly escaped death on 9/11, had grown increasingly disillusioned with the banking world, especially after witnessing the unjust bonuses awarded to Merrill Lynch executives during the financial crisis.

Schwall's anger at the corruption he saw led him to RBC, where his obsessive attention to detail became an asset. He was particularly fixated on Thor, a tool designed to level the playing field for investors. Schwall's deep dive into the history of market regulations revealed systemic issues that allowed HFT firms to exploit slower investors. This problem was exacerbated by Reg NMS, a set of rules that aimed to improve U.S. exchanges through fairness in price execution.

One pivotal moment came when Schwall spent an entire night researching the origins of front-running in the stock market. His findings highlighted the continuous cycle of regulatory loopholes being exploited, leading to new forms of front-running. Schwall's relentless investigation and the resentment he felt toward the injustice fueled his determination to uncover and address these issues.

The team’s efforts led to the development of Thor, which initially saw success. However, their progress plateaued as clients felt compelled to continue relationships with major Wall Street banks despite preferring Thor. This frustration was compounded when Brad discovered that Wall Street banks were imitating Thor's technology and offering lucrative incentives to poach his team members.

Rich Gates, another key figure, ran tests to expose the predatory practices within Wall Street's dark pools. His findings, initially focused on Goldman Sachs, revealed widespread exploitation by HFT firms. These tests eventually caught the attention of the SEC, although regulatory action was slow.

Faced with the realization that the big banks were unlikely to change their ways, Brad and his team considered creating their own stock exchange to protect investors. This idea gained traction, but it became clear that the exchange needed to be independent of any Wall Street bank to gain credibility.

As they moved forward, Schwall's LinkedIn investigations provided crucial insights into the networks of HFT firms and their connections to major banks. His findings showed that many technologists involved in high-frequency trading were oblivious to the broader implications of their work, often detailing their roles in ways that exposed the banks' true activities.

In early 2013, the team’s resolve to create a fairer stock market solidified. They believed that eliminating unnecessary intermediaries could address the systemic issues plaguing the market. This mission would require significant sacrifices and a united front against the entrenched interests of Wall Street.

Brad and the Team's Battle Against Wall Street Predators: The Birth of Thor

Serge Aleynikov's journey from a reluctant Russian immigrant to a key player on Wall Street is nothing short of remarkable. In 1990, Serge left Russia with a deep sense of patriotism and a reluctance to embrace English. His Jewish heritage had restricted his academic pursuits in Russia, but his passion for computer programming was undeniable. At sixteen, he wrote his first program—a sine wave—and was instantly captivated by the intellectual and emotional satisfaction coding provided.

Upon arriving in New York, Serge was struck by the diversity and abundance of food. Despite his initial struggles with language and job applications, his coding talents soon landed him a position at a New Jersey medical center, followed by a role at Rutgers University, where he pursued a master's degree. His career progressed through internet startups until he joined IDT, a telecom company where he became the star technologist.

In 2007, a headhunter persuaded Serge to interview with Goldman Sachs, promising higher pay and new challenges. Despite his initial reluctance, he eventually joined Goldman, where he was tasked with improving their high-frequency trading (HFT) systems. Serge found himself in an environment that valued speed and immediate profit over long-term solutions, constantly patching an outdated and complex system.

Serge's skills were highly sought after, leading to job offers from other firms. In early 2009, he accepted an offer from a new hedge fund run by Misha Malyshev, which excited him with the prospect of building a trading platform from scratch. His departure from Goldman was amicable, but he made the mistake of sending himself code that included both open source and proprietary Goldman software, intending to disentangle them later.

This act led to his dramatic arrest by the FBI, prompted by Goldman Sachs. Serge was accused of stealing proprietary code, a charge he found bewildering given his understanding of open-source practices. Despite his explanations, the FBI, led by an agent new to law enforcement, did not fully grasp the technical nuances. Serge's confession, crafted under pressure, was used against him in court.

Ultimately, Serge Aleynikov was sentenced to eight years in federal prison, a stark end to a career marked by technical brilliance and a desire to solve complex problems. His story highlights the clash between individual talent and the opaque, high-stakes world of Wall Street trading.

Is Serge Aleynikov a Victim or Villain in the High-Frequency Trading Drama?

In 2011, Ronan was preparing for his annual trip back to Ireland, intent on reassuring his father about his success on Wall Street. The Irish economy had collapsed, and many of his childhood friends were still jobless. Ronan’s career had flourished, but now he faced a dilemma. Brad Katsuyama, his boss at RBC, proposed creating a new stock exchange, IEX, aimed at restoring fairness to the U.S. stock market.

At RBC, Ronan had uncovered the unsettling reality of Wall Street: the market was riddled with predatory practices, largely due to high-frequency trading (HFT). Brad’s plan was to build a new kind of exchange that would eliminate such unfair advantages. Convincing Ronan to join this risky venture involved a heartfelt conversation with his father, who, after hearing Ronan's substantial bonus, advised, “Your risks seem to have paid off so far. Why the fuck not?”

Brad’s resignation from RBC marked the beginning of their mission. Despite doubts and financial hurdles, Brad and Ronan, along with their colleagues Rob Park and John Schwall, committed to this revolutionary idea. They aimed to build IEX, not just as another exchange but as one that could genuinely be trusted by investors.

The team brought in experts like Don Bollerman and Francis Chung, who, together with the “Puzzle Masters,” dissected and redesigned the market’s mechanics to prevent HFT from exploiting ordinary investors. Their goal was to create a level playing field, free from the predatory strategies that had corrupted other exchanges.

To achieve this, they developed innovative solutions like coiling fiber optic cables to simulate physical distance, ensuring that no trader could gain an unfair speed advantage. They simplified order types and eliminated rebates, which had been a major tool for HFT firms to game the system.

The challenge was not just technical but also political. Convincing investors and brokers to trust and use IEX required strategic thinking. Matt Trudeau, who had previously opened new exchanges globally, joined the team, bringing a unique perspective. They brainstormed ways to ensure transparency and accountability, considering ideas like real-time monitoring to keep brokers honest.

Despite internal debates and external skepticism, the team remained united in their vision. They knew that changing Wall Street meant taking on powerful interests, but they were driven by a shared commitment to fairness and integrity.

As they moved forward, they encountered numerous obstacles but also found unexpected allies among investors who were tired of the status quo. By mid-2013, they had raised the necessary capital and were ready to launch IEX. Their journey was a testament to the power of idealism, innovation, and relentless pursuit of a fairer financial system.

Ronan, Brad, and their team were not just building a stock exchange; they were challenging the very foundations of Wall Street, proving that with the right vision and determination, even the most entrenched systems could be reformed.

Redefining Wall Street: The Birth of IEX and the Pursuit of a Fairer Financial System

On the morning of September 11, 2001, Zoran Perkov was running late for his tech help desk job at Wall Street Systems, just next door to the New York Stock Exchange. As he ascended from the subway into the morning light, he witnessed the second plane hit the South Tower and chaos ensued. 

Amidst the panic, he helped guide an old man with a cane to safety and later found shelter with a friend in the American Express building. This experience, though harrowing, revealed to Zoran his natural aptitude for staying calm in crises and kindled a newfound interest in helping others.

Fast forward to 2006, Zoran was managing electronic stock markets at Nasdaq, a job he found exhilarating due to its high stakes. His journey wasn’t without mishaps; he once inadvertently shut down the market for 22 seconds. This incident spurred his deep dive into managing complex systems, a study that informed his approach to stabilizing unpredictable environments.

By 2012, Zoran found himself disillusioned with the increasing complexity and arbitrary changes demanded by high-frequency traders (HFT) at Nasdaq. Shortly after being fired, he received a call from Don Bollerman asking him to join a start-up called IEX, aimed at creating a fair stock market. Despite initial skepticism and social friction with his new colleagues, Zoran’s expertise in crisis management and complex systems became invaluable.

IEX aimed to challenge the opaque and manipulative practices of existing markets. When it launched on October 25, 2013, Zoran opened the market. The team faced skepticism and sabotage from big Wall Street banks, who were reluctant to route orders to the new exchange. However, an unexpected ally emerged: Goldman Sachs. On December 19, 2013, Goldman sent a surge of orders to IEX, validating its mission and setting a precedent for other banks.

IEX’s transparent and fair trading mechanisms began to expose the predatory practices of HFT and the complicity of big banks. They revealed how banks often manipulated orders to benefit their own dark pools, increasing costs for investors. With Goldman’s support, IEX started to gain traction, challenging the status quo and pushing for a market that prioritized fairness and transparency over profit-driven manipulation.

Brad Katsuyama, CEO of IEX, exemplified the moral and practical drive behind the mission. By the end of 2013, IEX had demonstrated that change was possible, showing that a fair market could exist and thrive, provided investors and brokers were willing to support it. This narrative of resilience, ethics, and innovation in the face of systemic corruption highlights the transformative potential of integrity in financial markets.

Did Goldman Sachs Help Transform Wall Street by Backing IEX's Fair Trading Revolution?

Sergey Aleynikov's trial in December 2010 was a spectacle of confusion, where jurors lacked the knowledge to understand high-frequency trading (HFT), and expert witnesses were barely experts. Despite this, the trial had lasting impacts on Wall Street software developers, sending a clear message: taking code could land you in jail.

Aleynikov had moved code from Goldman Sachs to his new employer, Teza Technologies. The code wasn't particularly valuable outside Goldman, but its removal unsettled the firm. As one juror noted, taking code was like taking a spiral notebook from a previous job—useful to remember past work but not crucial for new tasks. 

Goldman Sachs called the FBI, leading to Aleynikov's arrest and trial. The case highlighted the murky intersection of technology and finance, where even those involved couldn't fully grasp the implications. The trial ended with Aleynikov's conviction, but his calm demeanor throughout was puzzling to those around him. He saw his ordeal as a life lesson, rather than a tragedy.

After his conviction was overturned, Aleynikov was rearrested under new charges, underscoring the relentless pursuit by authorities. Despite these setbacks, Aleynikov remained unbroken, finding solace in his family and new perspectives on life.

Goldman Sachs's involvement in Aleynikov's case was part of a broader realization: the bank couldn't compete with the speed of HFT firms. By 2013, Goldman had shifted strategies, supporting initiatives like IEX, which aimed to create a fairer stock market. This pivot reflected a recognition that their traditional advantages were eroding in the face of rapid technological advancements.

Aleynikov's story is a microcosm of the larger struggles within Wall Street, where the quest for speed and efficiency often collides with ethical and legal boundaries. His journey from arrest to a redefined sense of purpose serves as a reminder of the complexities and human costs behind the financial industry's relentless drive for innovation.

Code, Conviction, and Wall Street: The Sergey Aleynikov Saga

In the high-stakes world of Wall Street, the advent of high-frequency trading (HFT) brought forth new players and possibilities, as well as controversies and questions about fairness and transparency. At the heart of this transformation was Sergey Aleynikov, a Russian programmer accused of stealing trading code from Goldman Sachs, which sparked a deeper examination of the secretive world of HFT.

The rise of HFT led to the development of complex, computer-driven operations that often left average investors in the dark about the true mechanics of their trades. This highlighted the need for a level playing field in an industry that valued speed and immediacy. 

One effort to address this was the ambitious project by Dan Spivey, funded by former Netscape CEO Jim Barksdale, to create the fastest trading route by laying fiber optic strands between a Chicago data center and a New Jersey stock exchange. Their company, Spread Networks, achieved this by going through mountains and under rivers to provide an edge to those who could afford it.

Another key figure in the fight for fairness was Brad Katsuyama, who worked for the Royal Bank of Canada (RBC). After witnessing the aggressive and debt-driven culture of Wall Street, Katsuyama, along with programmer Rob Park, developed Thor, a tool that synchronized the times at which orders reached different exchanges, preventing front-running by HFTs. 

Despite the success of Thor, Katsuyama and his team faced challenges as Wall Street banks began imitating Thor's technology and offering incentives to poach his team members. This led to the idea of creating their own stock exchange, IEX, independent of any Wall Street bank to ensure credibility. 

The journey to build IEX was fraught with obstacles, including the need to convince investors and brokers to trust and use it. Nonetheless, the team persisted and by mid-2013, had raised the necessary capital to launch IEX. The launch marked a significant step towards a fairer financial system, proving that even the most entrenched systems could be reformed.

However, the story of Aleynikov serves as a reminder of the human costs and complexities involved in this relentless drive for innovation. Despite being sentenced to eight years in federal prison for stealing proprietary code, Aleynikov's ordeal became a life lesson rather than a tragedy, highlighting the often-murky intersection of technology and finance.


Home

Trending Books

News & Mags

Relax

Curated

Collections

Key Ideas & Notes

Insights

Highlights & Bookmarks

Listening History

Flash Boys: A Wall Street Revolt

Michael Lewis

Ready to dive into the secretive world of high-frequency trading?

Curious about how a few determined individuals dared to challenge the entrenched norms of Wall Street?

Intrigued about how a Russian programmer's arrest unveiled the immense power of market-manipulating software?

Join us as we unravel the journey of Brad Katsuyama, Ronan Ryan, and Sergey Aleynikov, and their fight for transparency and fairness amidst the chaotic landscape of modern financial trading.

Key Ideas

#1