Curious about the intriguing journey of a former U.S. Attorney, who once worked under Rudy Giuliani and later led the FBI? Interested in understanding the delicate balance between political imperatives and ethical boundaries in the realm of national security? How about exploring the challenges faced by law enforcement amidst racial tensions and systemic discrimination? Uncover all this and more in this riveting narrative.

A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies, and Leadership

In 1992, as an Assistant U.S. Attorney in New York City, James Comey, the author, was introduced to the world of the Mafia by none other than Salvatore “Sammy the Bull” Gravano. 

Gravano was a high-ranking mobster who turned federal witness, revealing the Mafia's strict code of lies and loyalty. This secretive society, known as La Cosa Nostra, inducted new members through a ceremony involving blood oaths and flaming pictures of saints, but their supposed rules were often broken. Gravano's cooperation was crucial in dismantling the Mafia's hold, despite his past of nineteen murders.

Comey's path to law enforcement was shaped by a traumatic encounter with a gunman during his teenage years. This life-threatening experience taught him to value life and justice, guiding him toward a career in law. After studying law, he joined the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Manhattan, where he worked under Rudy Giuliani, known for his aggressive stance against organized crime.

Together with his colleague Patrick Fitzgerald, Comey took on the Gambino crime family, learning the intricacies of Mafia operations from experts like Kenneth McCabe. The case involved meeting Mafia turncoats like Gravano and Sicilian Mafia killer Francesco Marino Mannoia, who shared chilling tales of murder and deceit. These interactions revealed the Mafia's twisted sense of honor and the ease with which these men justified their actions.

Despite the Mafia's notorious reputation, we succeeded in weakening their grip on unions and crime, thanks to the efforts of dedicated investigators and prosecutors. The Mafia's influence dwindled, leaving behind a shadow of its former power. Through these experiences, Comey learned that true justice requires confronting evil with truth and integrity, even when the path is fraught with danger and moral complexity.

Can Sammy's Betrayal Truly Dismantle the Mafia's Legacy?

Bullies often feed on insecurities, and Comey witnessed this firsthand during his childhood. Moving from Yonkers, New York, to Allendale, New Jersey, Comey went from a popular kid to a bullying target. Despite his eventual six-foot-eight height, he wasn't always imposing. Bullies targeted Comey because he was different—he wore thrift clothes, had a New York accent, and was smart and verbal. His attempts to reason with them failed, and he spent years avoiding confrontation.

Luckily, Comey found solace in close friends and supportive adults. His parents, tough but kind, encouraged them to "rise and shine," and his mom always believed he had great potential. He also connected with teachers and worked part-time at a grocery store under Harry Howell, a great leader who balanced discipline with compassion.

College brought new challenges. Despite his upbringing and values, Comey succumbed to peer pressure and bullied a fellow student. This experience taught him a valuable lesson about moral authority and the tendency to follow the herd. It was painful, but it made him despise bullies and sympathize with their victims.

His wife Patrice and two women taught Comey about leadership and life. After leaving a law firm for public service, Comey worked under Helen Fahey, a U.S. Attorney who fostered his growth and was confident enough to be humble. Her leadership taught Comey the importance of supporting others and not worrying about reputation.

Patrice, his most significant teacher, showed resilience after their newborn son, Collin, died from an infection. She channeled her grief into a nationwide campaign to change testing standards for Group B strep to save mothers from experiencing their pain. Her determination influenced Comey's view of justice and the law.

Despite planning to stay in Richmond, the events of 9/11 led to a call from the White House, asking Comey to be the U.S. Attorney in New York. Although this meant uprooting their family, Patrice and Comey agreed that serving their country was important. They returned to New York, ready to face new challenges with purpose and resilience.

From Bullied to U.S. Attorney: A Journey of Resilience and Redemption

When Martha Stewart was released from prison in March 2005, people were buzzing about her net worth growing during her time in custody. The media was eager to get a reaction from James Comey, the U.S. Attorney who had indicted her. When a reporter asked how he felt about Stewart being $200 million richer, Comey responded with a practiced line, "Well, we at the Department of Justice are all about the successful reentry of our inmates into society."

Stewart's case had initially seemed minor to Comey compared to other significant cases, but it underscored the importance of integrity. Stewart lied about insider trading, and instead of admitting it, she constructed a false narrative, involving others in her deception. This behavior led to her conviction, demonstrating the danger of small lies evolving into habitual deceit.

Comey had his own experience with a seemingly harmless lie. During his early years, he would nod or say "yup" when strangers asked if he played college basketball, even though he hadn't. This small lie bothered him, leading him to confess the truth to his friends later.

In 2002, Comey handled the high-profile case of Sam Waksal, the owner of ImClone, who was caught in insider trading. Martha Stewart, a friend of Waksal, sold her ImClone shares based on inside information. Instead of admitting the truth, she lied to investigators, leading to her prosecution.

Comey emphasized that lying within the justice system undermines its foundation. He drew parallels between Stewart's case and the case of a young minister from Richmond who lied to protect his mentor, Mayor Leonidas Young, and ended up in prison.

Comey's career in law enforcement included handling significant cases, like the prosecution of insider trading and corporate fraud. These experiences taught him the importance of honesty and the dangers of creating a culture of deceit. His dedication to integrity and the rule of law remained a guiding principle throughout his career.

Did Insider Trading Make Martha Stewart $200 Million?

In April 2004, shocking images of prisoner mistreatment at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq surfaced, revealing American soldiers abusing Iraqi detainees. This scandal hit hard, especially with an upcoming presidential election, and led to public apologies and promises of investigations from high-ranking officials. At the same time, the CIA was worried about its own clandestine interrogation program, which involved tactics like waterboarding.

The legal definition of "torture" in American law, outlined by Congress in 1994, required the infliction of "severe" mental or physical pain or suffering. This definition, post-9/11, was used to justify harsh interrogation tactics on captured Al Qaeda leaders, believed to be essential for national security. However, Jack Goldsmith, head of the Office of Legal Counsel, identified flaws in the legal opinions justifying these tactics and, with support, moved to withdraw them.

Goldsmith's withdrawal led to tensions with the Bush administration, particularly with figures like Vice President Cheney, who held strong beliefs about the necessity and effectiveness of enhanced interrogations. The struggle highlighted a broader issue of confirmation bias, where leaders, driven by political culture, found it hard to admit doubt or mistakes.

The narrative of confirmation bias extended to the Justice Department's role—balancing political imperatives with impartial justice. Leaders faced the challenge of maintaining independence while responding to political pressures, akin to navigating turbulent waters. This tension was illustrated when Alberto Gonzales became attorney general, succeeding John Ashcroft, and faced pressure to produce legal opinions in line with White House expectations.

Gonzales's tenure saw continued debates over interrogation policies, with internal voices advocating for careful legal consideration. These struggles underscored the importance of leadership integrity and the challenges of maintaining ethical standards amidst political pressure.

Years later, in 2013, James Comey was nominated by President Obama to lead the FBI, emphasizing the need for competence and independence in the role. Comey, with a background in both public service and the private sector, was committed to transforming the FBI's culture and leadership, focusing on diversity, integrity, and transparency. He sought to learn from history, promoting a curriculum on the FBI's past interactions with civil rights figures like Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., to ensure the agency's values aligned with justice and accountability.

Comey’s leadership journey underscored the importance of questioning assumptions, fostering open dialogue, and learning from past mistakes to avoid repeating them. Through transparency and a commitment to ethical leadership, he aimed to position the FBI as a model of integrity and excellence.

From Abu Ghraib Scandal to Comey's FBI Reform

In 2014 and 2015, the deaths of black civilians like Eric Garner, Tamir Rice, Walter Scott, and Freddie Gray during police encounters sparked national outrage and highlighted systemic discrimination. The incident that truly ignited the fire was the shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri. 

The subsequent federal investigation uncovered a pattern of discriminatory policing, but found insufficient evidence to charge the officer with federal crimes. This did little to quell public anger fueled by viral videos of police violence, leading to increased distrust between law enforcement and black communities.

Amid this turmoil, President Obama tasked the FBI with fostering dialogue between police and communities. In February 2015, Comey delivered a speech at Georgetown University highlighting "hard truths" about law enforcement's historical bias and the impact of implicit biases. Despite efforts to bridge the gap, anger on both sides persisted.

In the summer of 2015, a surge in murders in major cities, primarily affecting young black men, puzzled law enforcement. Comey speculated that viral videos and changing police behavior might be contributing factors, sparking controversy. Despite criticism from both political sides, he felt compelled to address the issue.

President Obama, in a private conversation, demonstrated his extraordinary listening skills, engaging in an open dialogue about race, law enforcement, and societal issues. The conversation was a rare example of true listening in Washington's political landscape.

This period was marked by a challenging interplay between privacy, public safety, and the role of technology companies like Apple and Google, who moved towards default encryption, complicating law enforcement efforts. Despite differing perspectives, a resolution remained elusive.

The political climate also affected the FBI's investigation into Hillary Clinton's email practices. Despite finding classified information mishandled, there was insufficient evidence to prove criminal intent. The investigation's outcome was controversial, leading to public statements to maintain transparency and trust in the justice system. Ultimately, the goal was to uphold a higher loyalty to justice, despite the personal and institutional challenges.

Did Obama's FBI Intervention Bridge the Gap Between Police and Black Communities?

In the summer of 2016, the FBI was investigating Russian interference in the election. Evidence suggested that Russia aimed to undermine American democracy, harm Hillary Clinton, and support Donald Trump. This was fueled by Putin's personal animosity towards Clinton, whom he blamed for protests in Moscow in 2011. The Russians released damaging emails from the Democratic Party and targeted voter registration databases.

In late July, the FBI learned that Trump campaign advisor George Papadopoulos discussed obtaining Clinton-damaging emails from Russia. This led to an investigation into potential collaboration between Americans, including Trump campaign members, and the Russians.

The FBI kept the investigation confidential but faced a dilemma in October when new emails related to Clinton were found on Anthony Weiner's laptop. With the election imminent, FBI Director James Comey had to choose between revealing the investigation or concealing it, both of which had significant implications.

Despite the norm of avoiding actions that could impact elections, Comey decided to inform Congress about the emails, believing that concealing this information would damage the FBI's integrity. This decision was met with backlash from both Clinton supporters and Trump allies.

After Trump was elected, Comey and other intelligence leaders briefed him on Russia's interference, including unverified allegations from the Steele dossier that Russia had compromising material on Trump. This briefing, conducted privately with Trump, was uncomfortable and surreal for Comey.

Trump's reaction to the dossier was defensive, emphasizing his innocence and bringing up unrelated sexual assault allegations. Comey's assurance that the FBI was not investigating Trump seemed to calm him.

The situation highlighted the tension between the FBI's role in protecting the presidency from coercion and the potential perception of political bias. Ultimately, Comey's decisions were driven by a commitment to maintaining the FBI's credibility and independence, even as they navigated unprecedented political challenges.

FBI's 2016 Election Dilemma: Comey, Clinton, and the Trump-Russia Probe

In January 2017, Donald Trump was inaugurated as the 45th president of the United States. The size of his inauguration crowd quickly became a subject of controversy, with Trump insisting it was the largest ever, despite evidence to the contrary. This insistence on falsehoods concerned James Comey and others dedicated to truth, whether in criminal investigations or in assessing national security threats.

Two days after the inauguration, Comey attended a White House reception for law enforcement leaders who had supported the event. Although hesitant about appearing too close to Trump, he chose to attend, striving to maintain professionalism. 

At the reception, Comey tried to stay in the background, blending in with the blue curtains, but Trump spotted him. The president called him over, remarking that Comey was "more famous" than him, and attempted a televised hug. Comey managed to avoid the embrace, though the moment appeared on camera as a kiss.

During a private dinner with Trump, the president expressed a desire for loyalty, which Comey resisted by offering only "honest loyalty." He explained the critical need for the FBI's independence from the White House and emphasized that ethical leaders do not demand loyalty but instead cultivate environments where truth is valued. 

As Trump continued to press for a pledge, Comey realized that the president lacked an understanding of genuine leadership, which requires balancing toughness with kindness, confidence with humility, and a commitment to truth. This realization left Comey concerned about the future of the country under Trump's administration.

In early 2017, Comey met with White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus to discuss the proper boundaries of interaction between the FBI and the White House. Following their discussion, Priebus brought Comey to see Trump, who seemed preoccupied with defending his controversial interview comments equating America's actions to those of Vladimir Putin's regime. 

Comey challenged Trump, asserting that the United States does not engage in the kinds of killings attributed to Putin's regime. This moment likely ended any personal rapport between the two, but it reinforced Comey's dedication to the truth.

In February, Trump fired National Security Advisor Mike Flynn for lying about his conversations with the Russian ambassador. In a subsequent private conversation, Trump expressed his hope that Comey would drop the investigation into Flynn—a deeply troubling request that undermined the FBI's independence. Aware of Trump's tendency to misrepresent conversations, Comey meticulously documented these interactions.

Throughout his tenure, Comey received repeated calls from Trump, who voiced concerns about the Russia investigation, describing it as a "cloud" over his presidency. Trump urged Comey to publicly state that he was not personally under investigation, but Comey resisted, prioritizing the integrity of the FBI over political pressure.

In May 2017, Comey was abruptly fired, learning of his dismissal through television reports while addressing FBI employees. The firing was based on false claims and occurred without courtesy or explanation. Despite the shock, Comey remained steadfast in his commitment to the FBI's mission of protecting the American people and upholding the Constitution.

Comey reflects on these events during a time of national anxiety, expressing his belief that America will recover. He acknowledges that Trump’s presidency has tested the country's core values but observes that ethical leaders have worked to contain the damage.

Did Trump's Quest for Loyalty Spark a Crisis?

In 1992, James Comey, as an Assistant U.S. Attorney, was catapulted into the Mafia's world, thanks to Salvatore "Sammy the Bull" Gravano, a high-ranking mobster who turned federal witness. Gravano's revelations exposed the Mafia's fractured code of honor, playing a critical role in crippling their influence. This experience was a key moment in Comey's career, reinforced by a traumatic teenage encounter with a gunman that steered him toward law enforcement.

Working under Rudy Giuliani, Comey tackled the Gambino crime family, learning from Mafia insiders like Gravano and Francesco Marino Mannoia. These insights into the Mafia's twisted ethics were pivotal in dismantling their grip on unions and crime.

Comey's early life was marked by bullying after moving to New Jersey, where he was targeted for being different. Despite his towering height, he struggled with bullies, finding solace in supportive friends and mentors. His college years taught him painful lessons about peer pressure and moral authority, shaping his disdain for bullies.

After leaving a law firm, Comey worked under Helen Fahey, a humble leader who prioritized personal growth over reputation. His wife, Patrice, influenced his perspective on justice following their son's tragic death, channeling her grief into advocacy.

The events of 9/11 led to Comey's return to New York as U.S. Attorney, tackling cases like Martha Stewart's insider trading scandal. Stewart's lies underscored the dangers of deceit, a lesson mirrored in Comey's own small fibs about playing college basketball.

Comey faced ethical dilemmas during his tenure, notably with interrogation tactics post-9/11. Tensions with the Bush administration highlighted issues of confirmation bias and political pressure, emphasizing the importance of leadership integrity.

In 2013, President Obama nominated Comey to lead the FBI, focusing on diversity, integrity, and transparency. Comey aimed to transform the FBI's culture by confronting its past, inspiring a commitment to ethical leadership.

The deaths of black civilians at police hands in 2014 and 2015 sparked national outrage, highlighting systemic discrimination. Comey's Georgetown University speech addressed law enforcement's historical biases, although public anger persisted.

Comey's tenure saw challenges in balancing privacy, security, and technology's role in law enforcement. The FBI's investigation into Hillary Clinton's emails and Russian election interference underscored tensions between transparency and political influence.

In 2016, the FBI discovered Clinton-related emails on Anthony Weiner's laptop, leading Comey to inform Congress, a decision met with backlash. The investigation into Russian interference revealed efforts to undermine democracy, further complicating the political landscape.

Comey's interactions with President Trump were fraught, marked by Trump's insistence on loyalty. Despite Trump's attempts to influence FBI investigations, Comey prioritized integrity, documenting interactions meticulously.

In May 2017, Comey was fired, learning of his dismissal through the media. Despite the shock, he remained committed to the FBI's mission and the values of truth and justice. Reflecting on these events, Comey expressed hope for America's resilience in upholding core values amidst political challenges.

Home

Trending Books

News & Mags

Relax

Curated

Collections

Key Ideas & Notes

Insights

Highlights & Bookmarks

Listening History

Curious about the intriguing journey of a former U.S. Attorney, who once worked under Rudy Giuliani and later led the FBI?

Interested in understanding the delicate balance between political imperatives and ethical boundaries in the realm of national security?

How about exploring the challenges faced by law enforcement amidst racial tensions and systemic discrimination?

Uncover all this and more in this riveting narrative.

Improve your Career, Health & Life with 15min insights from 9000+ non-fiction books

Key Ideas

#1